Who: Artist, Writer, Creative type.
What: Hopeful. Affirming. Likes nifty gadgets, reading.
Where: See Internet.
Alignment: Creative Good.
----- Word Choice Assistance -----
Choose is different than chose, though they are closely related.
I chose to go forth and take the greater journey.
You choose to sit and watch the television.
Loose and lose are also different, but not quite so related.
I don't want to lose you, unless you want to be set loose.
Steak and stake are two completely different things.
I love steak, especially when it's juicy.
You should've staked that vampire while you had the chance.
Sparing and Sparring are two different things.
Sparing is when you save someone from something.
Sparring is when you mock-fight.
----- End Word Choice Assistance -----
----- Opinion Space -----
On the Use of "It's Canon" as an excuse.
1. The point of fan fiction is to change things around. If you don't change things around simply because you want to stay in completely in canon, I'm not entirely sure I'll continue reading your fiction.
2. If you, as an author, are arguing that your characterization is "in canon," it likely isn't. It's an interpretation of canon, sometimes and extrapolation of canon, but canon behavior is strictly what happened within the context of the show or its sequels. Not all extrapolations are equal and if you're justifying your version of canon to "bash" a character, then you're still very far from what is actually canon and right into something utterly different; possibly even OOC (For those who don't know, OOC is out of character).
3. Fanon and Canon are different things. Fanon is a semi-common extrapolation of canon that is seen often enough to sometimes justify tropes. Fanon is fun to play with, but writing an author to say that their use of "x" is wrong because "y," is pointless in the face of it.
4. All fan fiction is Alternate Universe, but some are more alternate than others. Thus, take the warning of AU seriously. The author is telling you that they plan on diverging from canon (and possibly fanon) by a possibly great degree. If you write an author to tell them that their character or situation is far from the original, then you're telling them something they already know and probably warned you about in the disclaimers.
Which brings me to:
The Importance of Disclaimers
Some authors will only disclaim the basics, but when an author lists out very specific details about what will be within a story, they are doing so for a reason. Most likely that reason is they are trying to avoid surprises for the reader and hedge against the resulting reviews and emails about how divergent or displeasing "x" is from the reader's expectations. Reading the disclaimers is an "audience," responsibility and a useful practice for those trying to avoid particular reading experiences.
Re-interpretation of the above: We all like to dive in to stories, but if you dive in without paying attention to signs, don't be surprised by the giant rocks at the bottom of the reading lake.
----- End Opinion Space -----
I figure, if I post it here, I won't get into anyone's hair about it in a review, as stuff like the above only really bothers me sometimes.
PLEASE NOTE: Some statistics are filtered by your maximum story rating selection and any global filters set in your profile. Graphs only update once a day.