Large PrintHandheldAudioRating
Twisting The Hellmouth Crossing Over Awards - Results
Rules for Challenges
Category Logo

Lord of the Rings • 438 stories • Updated 13 Dec

On the downside, there is no television, malls, hairspray or indoor plumbing. However, in compensation there are yummy elves, sons of man, dwarves, hobbits and more "demons" than you can shake a pointy stick at.

Enjoy our collection of Lord of the Rings crossover fanfiction where the denizens of the Buffy and Angel universe find themselves transported to Middle Earth. Will they help the fellowship return the one ring to Mount Doom, or will they be more interested in the pursuit of the affections Legolas and Aragon?

CategoriesAll StoriesChallenges
The Initiative of the Lord of the Rings

“Don’t touch that!” Maggie Walsh yelled, but it was too late, Buffy had already touched the shiny crystal. Then the lights went out. As the emergency, battery powered, lights came back on; Buffy could see everyone glaring at her.

Synopsis: Buffy, the Initiative base, and everyone inside it and the Frat house above them are transported somewhere. Preferably Middle Earth.


- No one in Middle Earth speaks English and no one in the Initiative speaks Westron (the Common Tongue). If you want, you can have a ...
Lord of the Rings > Buffy-Centered > Theme: Post Fellowship • Oxnate • Responses [0] • Date Added [9 Jan 14]
Glory's portal drops Buffy into Mirrormere, where she ends up saving Balin's life.

-Buffy comes through the portal injured, but this does not hinder her. She is used to fighting harder when already hurt.
-The troll hammer comes with her, which is what she uses to clobber the orcs in Dimrill Dale.
-Buffy speaks English and French. The dwarves speak Westron and Khuzdul. While they try to learn each other's language, they find other ways to communicate.
-Balin, Óin, and Ori must survive.

-The dwarves are confused by her presence, but also thankful. She is an excelle...
Lord of the Rings • AlizaMacina • Responses [0] • Date Added [30 Dec 13]
Galadriel had been having visions of a young elleth who had somehow been taken to another world. The young elleth was disguised by magic as a human and raised as one, but Galadriel could see past that and knew the truth. Buffy Summers was an elf and she belonged in Middle Earth not in some hell dimension with vampires. Stretching out her senses she sent and urgent summons to both Gandalf and her March Warden, Haldir. It was long past time they rescued this young elleth before her fea was broken altogether.

Write about how Galadriel saves Buffy from the hellmouth and her friends. If...
Lord of the Rings > Buffy-Centered • (Past Donor)FireDragon • Responses [1] • Date Added [26 Apr 13]
Now that The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey has been released, it’s high time we saw some more dwarf-centric stories in circulation. And because adding Buffy makes everything better…well, you know.

I’ve seen Buffy as an elf only about five million times, Buffy as a woman, and even Buffy as a hobbit (absolutely adorable, write more of those too, please)…but Buffy as an actual dwarven lass? An axe-wielding, tough as nails slayer-dwarf with a love for the shiny and the beginnings of a truly handsome lady-beard?*

The challenge is very simple. Craft a tale – of any length...
Lord of the Rings > Buffy-Centered • Nightmarish • Responses [0] • Date Added [4 Apr 13]
I would like to see something no ones tried before. Buffy becomes a wrymling thanks to Glorys portal. Or because she would have been a dragon in the middle earth/Forgotten Realms universe. She's barley one year of age or younger. Lands on top of a sleeping Smaug set 25 years before the Hobbit.

If you would like to add Forgotten Realms elements I request you have Smaug leave middle earth sometime after the Hobbit. Lets say he lives and escapes. The planes of reality would be weak still from Glory's half assed attempt to plane shift to her own world. So anyone with the power level ...
Lord of the Rings > Buffy-Centered > Pairing: Other LotR • ChikaraKatherine • Responses [0] • Date Added [4 Jun 12]
Gandalf mistakenly transports himself, Aragorn, Gimli, and Legolas into Sunnydale and has no idea how to get them back to Middle Earth.

Buffy and the Scoobie gang save them from demons/vampires.

Willow cannot be the one to transport them back.

Must be at least 500 words.
Lord of the Rings > General > Theme: In Sunnydale • poet • Responses [0] • Date Added [2 Mar 12]
What if one of the female members of the Scoobies is stranded in Middle-Earth during the Third Age? What if she meets Arwen and they fall in love with each other?
This should not be a tenth walker story. It should take place at least a century before the events of the trilogy.
It has to be femslash, because the pairing is Arwen/female Scooby. Male slash is NOT allowed, because there are no canon homosexual pairings in Middle-Earth.

A variation of that theme would be following:
After Buffy second death (in "The Gift") she finds herself in Middle-Earth several centuries befo...
Lord of the Rings • BarbarossaRotbart • Responses [0] • Date Added [17 Feb 12] • Date Updated [29 Jul 14]
1. Buffy ends up in the LOTR universe around the time that Sauron's created the Ring. Sauron's creates the ring using Buffy's blood, Buffy returns to Sunnydale (season 6) after that.

2. Time goes faster in Middle Earth then in the Buffy universe, so around season 7, characters from ME come to Sunnydale to bring Buffy back to ME because they need her there (because the ring is tied to her)

3.Buffy joins the fellowship to destroy the ring and Sauron.
Lord of the Rings > Buffy-Centered • Jave • Responses [0] • Date Added [10 Mar 11]
It's strange that there are no LotR fanfics featuring Oz, especially as Middle Earth has its own werewolves. I'd love to see Oz make his way to Ea as a werewolf or warg.

He may start out alone, with goblins, in a warg pack, or with Sauron's forces, but he must try to join up with the forces opposing Sauron. I would imagine Oz would be just as good at getting his point across without speech while canine as he did as a human.

Oz may be involved with the Fellowship or some other group of fighters against Saur...
Lord of the Rings > Other BtVS/AtS Characters • HebiR • Responses [0] • Date Added [22 Jan 11]
You all know the poem describing the rings in Lord of the Rings right? I challenge you to take that poem and twist it's reference into something else besides the rings of power.

The poem for those that do not know it:
Three Rings for the Elven-kings under the sky
Seven for the Dwarf-lords in their halls of stone
Nine for Mortal Men doomed to die
One for the Dark Lord on his dark throne
In the Land of Mordor where the Shadows lie
One Ring to rule them all, One Ring to find them
One Ring to bring them all and in the darkness bind them
In the Land of...
Lord of the Rings > General • Lindabvair • Responses [0] • Date Added [5 Aug 10] • Date Updated [8 Aug 10]
My Challenge is simple, I would like to see Buffy as an elfling and growing up as Legolas' little sister.

Things to include but not absolutely necessary

A) Buffy should die at the hands of the Master in the first series and be transferred to Middle Earth

B) Should arrive as an elfling and with no memories of her previous life.

The choice of where she originally arrives and how she gets there is up to you. It should include her interaction with King Thranduil and Legolas as well as the elves of Rivendell.

This should lead them onto participating in...
Lord of the Rings > Buffy-Centered > Theme: Fellowship • Angelica • Responses [0] • Date Added [11 Jul 10]
After the battle of Middle Earth and Sunnydale are over a portal drags Aragorn,Arwen,Legolas and Buffy into another World. A World where they have to fight daily in arena’s as slaves ( Gladiator style), and when they escape they still have a long road ahead to find a way back home.

Pairings: Buffy/Aragorn. Legolas/Arwen

Time line: After ROTK and Chosen. (time travels slower in the dimension where they are, so 10 years there is about 1 week in LOTR universe)

10.Must have:

1. Someone from the powers granting Buffy and Aragorn temporarily immortality so tha...
Lord of the Rings > Buffy-Centered > Pairing: Aragorn • Jave • Responses [0] • Date Added [22 May 10]
I was just re-watching the LotR trilogy last night and when I heard the title "witch-king of Angmar" and I had a vision of Willow challenging him over the title.

Afterwards I had some fun thinking up different ways of how the confrontation came about.
The most fun I came up with was that Willow was drunk while watching the movie and magicked herself there because she became angry that someone declared themselves king over her. In that one she just appeared in front of him staggering while he (and everyone else) stares at her. Then they stare even further when she uses her magic t...
Lord of the Rings > Willow-Centered • (Past Donor)mpop • Responses [1] • Date Added [8 Apr 10]
Either at the end of Season 1 as a result of closing the Hellmouth, Season 4 as a backlash of the enjoining spell, Season 5 as a portal went a little wonky, or Season 7 as a result of the Sunnydale Collapse, the Scoobies are dropped en masse in Lothlorien, just before (months) the Fellowship is formed. Whatever will they do?


1) at least one of the pairings is Buffy/Willow;

2) They affect the world at least commensurate with their powers - i.e., Buffy post S5 should do more than ride along with the fellowship.

3) There is a way to get back-not ...
Lord of the Rings > Buffy-Centered > Pairing: Other BtVS • (Current Donor)DeacBlue • Responses [0] • Date Added [29 Mar 10]
Elrond did not only raise Estel but a small human girl as well. Buffy (he that name does not sound human) and Aragorn grew up together until they were about 13 then a portal took Buffy to LA (and of course later on sunnydale). You can choose from the possibility of Aragorn going to Sunnydale to find buffy and taking her back home or buffy dropping back in Rivendell after the Gift.

Must have:

1. Fellowship timeline
2. Maybe start with buffy and aragorn as children or just use flashbacks
3. Aragorn and Buffy were always ''fighting'' and this continues when they meet ag...
Lord of the Rings > Buffy-Centered > Pairing: Aragorn • Jave • Responses [0] • Date Added [3 Feb 10]
Page: 1 of 4 next end
CategoriesAll StoriesChallenges