Review of chapter "Heroes" from MarcusSLazarus
Interesting bit of work, really; while I wish we'd had the chance to see how Buffy reacted to her other selves, it WAS kind of nice to see 'Catatonic' get the chance to be a hero.
Review By [MarcusSLazarus
] • Date [31 May 11] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Heroes" from Ponder
This was awesome. Thanks.
> I created The Slayer for my unpublished fic “We Don’t Need Another Hero.”
Please please post that here? I found a partial copy at the wayback machine and now I want to read the rest! :)
Review By [Ponder
] • Date [22 Mar 08] • Rating [9 out of 10]
Review of chapter "Welcome to Santa Carolita" from Saturn
Very neat idea. I like some of the other AU Buffys. I'll have to check for those fics they appear in. :)
Review By [Saturn
] • Date [1 Mar 08] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Heroes" from nicowa
Cool story. I'd suggest changing the summary and you might bring in more readers cos this is a very good story and it's surprising that it has so few hits.
Review By [nicowa
] • Date [13 Apr 07] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Welcome to Santa Carolita" from Shieldage
Heh, awesome. Great mid-canon settings. Er, I mean great having everyone brought in from different timelines and then returned to the stories already in progress. I hope Valey Girl winds up with her own gang of friends, shame she didn't get to hear any good tales of the Scoobies.
Fun Stuff :)
Review By [Shieldage
] • Date [26 Feb 07] • Rating [10 out of 10]
Review of chapter "Heroes" from Kiwikatipo
That was awesome. I'm reccing it. Very clever. I love A.U.s' Nasty Girl rocked.
However I must take extreme nit picky issue with America being the last free nation. Please don't make me puke. During WW2 the Soviet Union would have plugged on alone until they bet the Germans if needed. America entering the war in Dec 41 just sped the inevitable German defeat up. The Third Reich unlike the British Commonwealth (hello I think someone's forgetting resource rich Canada and South Africa) and the Soviet Union did not utilise their own patriotic females in factories and war work, because the Nazis were sexist as well as racist. Instead the Germans had Slavic and Semitic slave labour who tried to sabotage their slave masters every step and armanent they could. Ask yourself who would have won eventually?
I wouldn't take Resistance girl out in public again, I personally find your historical suppostiton offensive as a citzen of a Western Democracy that isn't the U.S.. But I can get over myself enough to laugh at the fact she only takes out five vampires a year and quite enjoys getting the chance to kill them.
Comments from author:
I'd hardly call the Soviet Union or South Africa free nations. Perhaps this universe came about because the US screwed up and decided to concentrate on defeating the Japanese, while the Germans took care of Europe -- we may have to agree to disagree on whether they could have succeeded. I think they came very close to doing so, and trust me, I give no short shrift to Western democracies that aren't the US.
Anyway, there are enough "Germans won World War II" works of fiction that I hardly regarded my using the backdrop as exceptionable.
I'm still glad you like the fic, though.
Rob aka Mediancat
Review By [Kiwikatipo
] • Date [25 Feb 07] • Rating [10 out of 10]