Review of chapter "Elemental" from bookworm
Haha! Once again, I enjoyed that thoroughly. 'Sherrinford' is another character we could certainly stand to see more of.
Review By [bookworm
] • Date [12 Jun 11] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Elemental" from SamJames
Groan. I wasn't expecting that, even with the title. But why change the detective's name?
Comments from author:
Sherrinford Holmes was the first name Arthur Conan Doyle gave to the Great Detective. Changed before publication, of course.
Rob aka Mediancat
Review By [SamJames
] • Date [24 Jun 07] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Elemental" from Sulien
Oh, my GODS, that's a bad pun! *grins* Brilliant.
I'm not a Holmesian myself (or whatever Holmes fans call themselves), but I would definitely enjoy reading more stories like this one.
Review By [Sulien
] • Date [28 Feb 07] • Rating [10 out of 10]
Review of chapter "Elemental" from Shieldage
Review By [Shieldage
] • Date [26 Feb 07] • Rating [9 out of 10]
Review of chapter "Elemental" from YademosEbyam
Ouch! < Throws peanuts > In truth, I wouldn't mind if this became a series (based on the classic "canon" mysteries), with Buffy becoming "Sherrinford's" new Watson. And while I'm not usually a proponent of the "Dumb Buffy" fic style, it might be interesting if her friends figured out his identity but she didn't (not current enough to be on her pop culture index), and they refused to tell her for some reason (either at Sherrinford's request, or for Giles who could decide that Buffy needed to learn "a more analytical approach to slaying"). Hmmm, "The Revello Drive Irregulars" isn't quite as pithy as Scoobies or Slayerettes, but I could get used to it. ;)
Review By [YademosEbyam
] • Date [25 Feb 07] • Rating [9 out of 10]