Review of chapter "Paper Saints" from clockworkorange
I love the idea of a demon passing on all of it's memories and the memories of everyone it's ever possessed when it dies. I'm insanely curious about how this broken and somewhat River Tam-like Rory would interact with Sam and Dean Winchester (especially with John's memories in her head, that's gotta be super weird considering she use to date someone who looked just like Sam). She'd probably be very useful to them though, with all the information she's got stuck in her head and all (assuming she'd be sane enough to share that information when it's needed).
Feel super bad for Rory (and Lorelai and Logan), though. GOD, the ANGST!
Any plans for a sequel?
Review By [clockworkorange
] • Date [9 Jul 12] • Rating [10 out of 10]
Review of chapter "Paper Saints" from oxymironic
I'm not sure what the point of having House in this was; It was barely worth mentioning. You've so let me down. But you're a great author and I'd love to see you hand at just a House/Gilmore Girls cross. I think Rory and House interaction would be great.
Review By [oxymironic
] • Date [20 Aug 09] • Rating [3 out of 10]
Review of chapter "Paper Saints" from jennzabelle
That was awesome. I loved how you started with doubt, the not-knowing that gnaws at the spirit and ended with Rory knowing too much. The creepiness and wicked joy of the demon's sledgehammer approach to removing Rory from the boundaries that delineated her life and kept her safe was perfect for that slightly detached, malicious perspective. The details of the priestly encounter and the motive behind it were perfect, especially briskly wiping the tears away before she set off to destroy her last foes. And I loved that you brought in the Dean/Sam?Dean thing as a throwaway at the end. I'd love to see an outsider's POV in a sequel about the brash brothers and the fragile, jumpy girl who knows medicine, demon hunting, all the languages and facts of the people who were hosts to the demon before her and hates all that knowledge. Hates the absense of doubt.
That was just really, really great.
Review By [jennzabelle
] • Date [4 Jul 08] • Rating [10 out of 10]
Review of chapter "Paper Saints" from Crydwyn
That was an amazing piece of work,
Succeeding again, though I know not how,
So good you inspired me to not lurk,
I have one word to say, and that is... WOW.
Happy Rhyming Review Day!
Review By [Crydwyn
] • Date [14 Mar 08] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Paper Saints" from RevDorothyL
Wow! Really disturbing (but, on the whole, not THAT much more disturbing than the 'canon' version of the last season or more of "Gilmore Girls" -- demonic possession of one or another of the major characters would explain so much about how messed up everybody's sense of self and their relationships to one another got!).
Review By [RevDorothyL
] • Date [8 Jan 08] • Rating [10 out of 10]
Review of chapter "Paper Saints" from LoreleiLynn
OK, wow. Certainly nothing I have ever considered. I loved the "guest appearance" by House, and the interesting way you incorporated Rory's doubts on the show with SPN canon. And like with your previous fic, I keep wanting more.
Review By [LoreleiLynn
] • Date [29 May 07] • Not Rated