Great story so far, but one this stands out like a sore thumb:
A British ex-Librarian not knowing the Harry Potter books. I'm sorry, that just isn't realistic. Giles knowing the books as fiction, or thinking the Scoobies are kidding makes sense (and I'm going to assume that "Giles doesn't know Harry Potter" means that Giles doesn't know any Buffyverse group that is the Harry Potter world), but Giles having never heard of the series does not.

Beyond that it's a great story so far, and I like how you made Faith a secret reader.

You have done a great job with this story and I hope you will get inspired to add more chapters to it.

::Gives the plot bunny a slice of Chocolate Apple Pie::

# = # = # = # = # = # = #
Neither fire nor wind,
birth nor death can
erase our good deeds.
- Buddha
# = # = # = # = # = # = #

Is this actually complete? It is not marked as such, but it's been a while and it could be, with an abrupt ending that is. Well either way, thanks for writing this, bye for now. PS, if this is not complete, could you finish it? Should only take a few more chapters, if that.

More please. It's been 7 years!

Will there be more of this story?

This is almost done, in fact its more done than most unfinished stories. Please post the end.

'Oh, my Magic Man! Oh!'"
---LOL!!!

This was a cute idea to have them spar together!

ha, cute idea with them recognizing each other :)

This is a wonderful story, is this finished as it is or do you plan on ever completing it?

Is there going to be more of this? Great story.

Please write more if you are NOT finished. if you ARE finished put that you are finished.

Wow, what a wonderful and thoughtful review. Thank you for telling me what you liked and/or disliked about the story and not being a pretentious ass with your expectations about what I should or shouldn't do with MY story. If, in the future, I decide that I don't want to write anything more, I'LL make the decision on how to label it.

If you don't like to read incomplete stories then I would suggest not reading stories that aren't labeled 'complete'. It's quite simple.

I loved this, I just wish there was an epilogue.

Brilliant story, My only complaint is that there isn't any more story at the moment.

So write more or bad things will happen to you.

Please, continue this story! Please!?