Review of chapter "Chapter Twenty-Two" from AutumnG
I would love to be able to read more of this specifically but I love all of your LotR/BtVS crossovers.
Review By [AutumnG
] • Date [14 Apr 13] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Chapter Twenty-Two" from EarlGrey
Wow, that was enjoyable!
Possibly your best story yet. As usuall you are very good at descriptions. Also I like that you gave Buffy normal life she always wanted - because Hobbit's life is simple and predictable-, that you gave her loving step-parents and equally loving step uncle and in this same time you show that she will never be really contend with normal life, that deep down she want adventure. I wonder if Buffy will ever be herself again, and if she would choose to be herself and try to go back to old life she had or she would prefer Buttercup persona, and normal life with caring uncle? I wonder what caused this transformation in the first place, what is the reason behind it? Is there piger plan here?
Love shenanigans were very funny - it's fun to see all those LOTR characters trying to get Buttercup's attention and win her love.
And c'mon you are stopping now, when they are finally ready to leave the Shire and go looking for adventure? I hope that someday you will continue this story. It's worth the effort!
Review By [EarlGrey
] • Date [25 Feb 13] • Rating [9 out of 10]
Review of chapter "Chapter Twenty-Two" from Jay
I'm really enjoying Buttercup! I assumed you created her for 'More Fierce Than Fire', but I'm happy to see you just continued using her character. I really like how you integrated Buffy into Buttercup using subtle hints =). I've been reading all of your Buffy/LOTR stories hoping and eagerly waiting to see if you would post another Buttercup/Thorin story! Thank you for adding some good reads into my evening. Thanks and happy holidays!
Review By [Jay
] • Date [24 Dec 12] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Chapter Twenty-Two" from HananeELmokkadem
Will you add more chapters to this story?
Please let me know?
Review By [HananeELmokkadem
] • Date [23 Dec 12] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Chapter Twenty-Two" from Gideon
Fantastic story! Very sad that little Buttercup couldn't save Frodo, but she seems to have done well for herself otherwise. She certainly has plenty of gentleman callers! I loved her letters to Gimli too, highly amusing. She really needed a second opinion if her intention was to repulse a dwarf. I hope she can rediscover her shape changing ability later on in life or Aragorn is not likely to consider her as wifely material :(
I am happy that this story stops at a reasonable stopping point too. The next bit could easily be another story. The first journey of Bilbo and Buttercup!
Review By [Gideon
] • Date [17 Dec 12] • Rating [9 out of 10]
Review of chapter "Chapter Twenty-Two" from Wiccachic
hope this will be completed one day was following ardently when it was more in progress.
Review By [Wiccachic
] • Date [16 Dec 12] • Rating [8 out of 10]
Review of chapter "Chapter Fifteen" from Dakaath
A battle axe and Bilbo's line have to be one of my favorite in the whole story.
Review By [Dakaath
] • Date [15 Dec 12] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Chapter Twenty-Two" from FireDragon
oh I long for more of this. It is so unique among LOTR stories. is there anything I can say to convince you to write more for us? Pretty please with sugar on top?
Review By [FireDragon
] • Date [27 Nov 12] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Chapter Twenty-Two" from Mistic
Original, creative, and never before seen. This wonderful creation has ensnared my imagination and all I can seem to think to myself now after all of this is "Lady in the Lake" granted not the movie or the book, just if you add a dash of water and a pinch of imagination and the Slayer is reborn! Ok it sounds much better in my mind but if you add dramatic, inspirational music to yours and read that out loud it might sound better...or not worth a try.
I must admit while I am curious about the physical metamorphosis between Buffy and Buttercup I am more anxious to learn about the changes this is going to inspire in the LoRt world. Does she meet Gandalf? What do the elves think of her? Why does Aragon search for her? How does she react or will she react to the ring? How will the tale differ from the original? Will you please, please, pleaseee cover it all? Why are Gimili's hair and beard two different colors?? You know the usual mundane questions one has after reading a story that corrupts their own imagination and they start trying to make fan fiction of fan fiction because they are desperate for more updates and can't imagine what's next and don't know all the facts.
Now comes that awkward moment when silence greets this previous statement. Yes I stalk this story actively...Yes I need better hobbies it's a work in progress, in the mean time however! Thank you for the brilliant story, wishing you much inspiration, many reviews, and better luck! Bye!
Review By [Mistic
] • Date [12 Nov 12] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Chapter Twenty-Two" from Nightscream
When you get this review I hope things will have gotten better for you and you're back up on your feet. I do hope that someday you'll come back to us here and continue to write and update these delightful stories. I have to say this was the first time I read this one. But it's such a fun read that I can't wait to read more.
Review By [Nightscream
] • Date [9 May 12] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Chapter Twenty-Two" from Luna
I really, really adore your writing. You write the LOTR'verse so wonderfully. Gimli and the others as suitors makes me smirk and I love that Aragorn got a vision of her.
Review By [Luna
] • Date [13 Feb 12] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Chapter Twenty-Two" from fran
I Like, I Lust, I Love!!Please Update Soon!!
Review By [fran
] • Date [10 Jan 12] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Chapter Twenty-Two" from garrycooper
Very, very good!!!!
Review By [garrycooper
] • Date [26 Dec 11] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Chapter Twenty-Two" from xLovingHeartsx
Please update this story soon! I absolutely love how you made Buffy a hobbit~! I know that you haven't updated this soon in a while but please update as soon as you can!
Review By [xLovingHeartsx
] • Date [21 Dec 11] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Chapter Twenty-Two" from TheGirlWhoWaited
I love this story! Please update it soon. I must read more!!
Review By [TheGirlWhoWaited
] • Date [10 Dec 11] • Rating [10 out of 10]