Review of chapter "Chapter One" from
delphinemalesReview:
Sequel please!!!!!
Review By [
delphinemales] • Date [9 Feb 10] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Chapter One" from
DarkestSlayerReview:
Okay what was with the heartless extraordinarily bitchy Buffy?
Review By [
DarkestSlayer] • Date [25 Oct 09] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Chapter One" from
KuroDraconisReview:
Awww you didn't finish it I wanted to know what the doctor's idea was. poor Wills. I hope you deciide to continue it
Review By [
KuroDraconis] • Date [23 Mar 09] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Chapter One" from
SailorsunReview:
Please, please, please continue this. It's a very interesting and promising premise.
Review By [
Sailorsun] • Date [17 Sep 08] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Chapter One" from
AerynSpeedleCaineReview:
You don't think very much of Buffy, do you?
It was a good story. But, I doubt Buffy would ever intentionally be that callous towards Willow, IMHO.
And yes, I REALLY don't like how you portrayed Buffy... It's not a direct criticism, per se; it's just you make it seem like Buffy would just thoughtlessly say kill them for no reason, and Buffy isn't like that (the Riley thing in 'Out of the Woods' notwithstanding).
The whole of the Dalek race needed to be killed off, because they would always come back, badder and more hell-bent (if you'll forgive the expression) on destroying human/alien-kind. That's how they're wired, so I don't think Buffy was in the wrong.
That said, I'm of a mixed opinion of this story. On the one hand, I enjoyed it; but on the other hand, I don't like how callous you made Buffy seem.
And forgive me, but I think in the entirety, Willow (and the others) so owe Buffy for dragging her out of Heaven in their misguided selfishness to have Buffy back- not because they needed a slayer there to protect Sunnydale- without even ATTEMPTING to see if Buffy really was in Hell.
I mean theoretically, Giles could have had the Watchers Council work on getting Faith released from prison to resume her duties as the Slayer, when he went back to England.
Because, I gotta say, that if Buffy had really been in hell, then I'm of the opinion that her body would have gone into that particular hell dimension as well ( like Angel's did in S2, Ep22: Becoming pt2; and when Buffy did in S3, Ep1: "Anne").
And then there was the whole kicking Buffy out when they didn't like her decisions as "The General" they all wanted her to be in Season Seven.
So yes, in the grand scheme of things, I think Buffy wasn't wrong or bad. And I don't think Buffy would EVER use the guilt trump card, because God knows there were plenty of instances when she was the wronged party, and she could have. The Scoobies are good at pointing out Buffy's faults, but they don't seem to like it when she even remotely mentions any of their shortcomings...
Review By [
AerynSpeedleCaine] • Date [18 Aug 08] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Chapter One" from
SaraBReview:
Very good.
Review By [
SaraB] • Date [10 Aug 08] • Rating [9 out of 10]
Review of chapter "Chapter One" from
RabidRejectReview:
Sweet.
Review By [
RabidReject] • Date [14 Jul 08] • Rating [10 out of 10]
Review of chapter "Chapter One" from
athenewolfeReview:
Excellant story! I really enjoyed the way that you integrated Willow, Buffy and the Slayers. Great story
Comments from author:
thank you.
Review By [
athenewolfe] • Date [8 Jul 08] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Chapter One" from
ShezziReview:
I liked this...are you going to do any more with it or is someone else allowed to come in and play? please? love xx Shezzi
Comments from author:
thanks.
and sry, i think i will.
sequels all jumping in my head.
Review By [
Shezzi] • Date [7 Jul 08] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Chapter One" from
TpelReview:
Freaking awesome!!!! Please write more!!
Review By [
Tpel] • Date [7 Jul 08] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Chapter One" from
MissingAuthorReview:
Very chilling, you are doing a fantastic job at getting across the emotions in your stories, plus love the scenes vividness.
Wispr
Comments from author:
*blush*
thank you. i try my best. and personally i think what makes a story good is if you can feel it, not just read a string of words.
Review By [
MissingAuthor] • Date [7 Jul 08] • Not Rated