Review of chapter "In Which Silas Meets Harry" from Stationary
id love to see how this all ends...
Review By [Stationary
] • Date [23 Feb 13] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "In Which Silas Meets Harry" from Calison
Fuck this is good keep on keeping on
Review By [Calison
] • Date [13 Sep 12] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "In Which Silas Meets Harry" from Letomo
I'm jsut sorry that this series appears to have been dropped, as it is so close to having an ending. It is a fascinating tale, that has kept me enthralled, in it's various tales, for two days.
And, I like that we are seeing a Silas version. It's interesting that he knows that he has about half the knowledge of the universe in his head, but is too slow thinking to really understand it, or make use of it. I really want to read more!
Review By [Letomo
] • Date [14 Jun 12] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "In Which Silas Meets Harry" from Fayari
This sort of ignored the fact that James was an ass, right? But I guess even an ass can love his family.
Comments from author:
Oh yeah, I completely agree about James being an ass and a bully, but that kind of fits with all the Horsemen's M.O. If I ever get back to finishing this story up you'll get to see that Silas can have a very dark side.
Review By [Fayari
] • Date [13 Feb 12] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "In Which Silas Meets Harry" from Downery
Judging by the title this would have been the last in the series. Wish you finished it but i'm just thankful for the stories in this series you did write.
Been ignoring this series because i avoid Willow centered stories and i thought the series would be mostly about Willow but i'm glad i was bored enough to start this series because it's been really fun to read.
Hope you start again.
Review By [Downery
] • Date [10 Jan 12] • Rating [10 out of 10]
Review of chapter "In Which Silas Meets Harry" from misdom
I've just re-read your entire series again for the 3rd or 4th time, I can't remember and I absolutely love it. I really hope you finish it.
Let me know if you need anything to help you finish it.
Review By [misdom
] • Date [19 Dec 11] • Rating [10 out of 10]
Review of chapter "In Which Silas Meets Harry" from lunalurker
Hi! I just tripped over this series recently, after encountering your new story and liking it more than enough to check your previous work, and ended up tearing through the whole thing. Enjoyed it thoroughly! I don't know a lot about Highlander, but most of it was pretty easily figured out by context and such, and it was definitely a unique take on the evolution of Willow and Xander. The only quibble I could come up with was that Cassandra's sacrifice didn't seem to make any obvious changes in our heroes having more of a conscience again, or even being less prone to genocide when grumpy. Ah well.
I hope you come back and finish the tale someday soon. May your muses be plentiful and writers blocks few and far between. Best of luck and thanks so much for writing! :)
Review By [lunalurker
] • Date [17 Aug 11] • Rating [9 out of 10]
Review of chapter "In Which Silas Meets Harry" from Oxnate
10 is my review for the entire series. I just finished the whole thing in a 2 day marathon reading. Great stuff.
I like how unique this story is. Willow and Xander as part of the 4 horsemen was awesome and I love how they matured as people from there.
I hope your muse returns soon. I would love to see how this series ends.
Review By [Oxnate
] • Date [15 Aug 11] • Rating [10 out of 10]
Review of chapter "In Which Silas Meets Harry" from Teucrian
Awesome series, hope you write some more sometime!
Review By [Teucrian
] • Date [6 Apr 11] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "In Which Silas Meets Harry" from malchance
I know that it has been two years since you last updated this fic, but I hope you plan to continue writing soon. I dearly want to know what happened to Methos and Xander. I hope you have plans to somehow bring them back. They (especially Methos) are my favorite characters.
I just read this series straight through and I couldn't stop. You have created a very complex yet enjoyable plot and I can't wait to read more.
Comments from author:
Jeez two years... That's kind of embarrassing. Truth is I've had a pretty bad case of writers block when it comes to this story. I know how it ends, and a fairly detailed sketch of how it gets there, but I just can't get the words on paper:(
I'm actually hoping to start posting a Ron-centric non crossover here soon if my beta ever gets the chapters back to me. Hopefully writing in the Harry Potter verse will get me unstuck on Their Final Adventure:)
Review By [malchance
] • Date [2 Apr 11] • Rating [10 out of 10]
Review of chapter "In Which Silas Meets Harry" from Sdarian
This series has been pretty great. I'll admit that I have no knowledge about Anita Blake, and it was quite the bummer that Xander died, but I'll stick with this and see how it goes. Keep up the good work!
Review By [Sdarian
] • Date [9 Mar 11] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "In Which Silas Meets Harry" from DoodlePenguin
You know iv read this series probably a dozen times over the last several years.... It's still the fucking Best Buffy-MultiVerse I have ever read. Even if it is unfinished. I just wanted to put that out there. While I would Love to see where this one goes. It's not gonna stop me from reading the series again sometime if you never update
Comments from author:
Thanks for the review. I've been working on some fanfic for the first time in a couple of years, unfortunately the writing bug for this series has refused to wake. I blame Harry, he's always been difficult. I'll probably start posting the other stuff on my fanfiction.net account in a couple of months if you are interested. My pen name there is thesharminator.
Review By [DoodlePenguin
] • Date [26 Jan 11] • Rating [10 out of 10]
Review of chapter "In Which Silas Meets Harry" from BerserkerNW
Interesting story. Still a little sad that Methos and Xander are dead. Is Willow going to be wolfy for the whole story, or will she come back to herself eventually? Thanks for sharing this! So, who were the other two incarnated as? I can see Xander as Sirius pretty easily, but then who is/was Methos? Thanks for sharing this!
Comments from author:
I won't give away plot details about Willow and her grieving process, but I can tell you who Methos' avatar is. You are right about Xander/Sirius loyalty defines them both in my opinion, more than courage, more than intellect. That leaves only one marauder for the old man, Peter. It's funny, when I first came up with the idea of the Four taking avatars, Peter as Methos was one of the first of all the fandoms to 'fit'. Just like Methos, Peter is the consummate survivor. Just like Methos, Peter betrays his brothers. Unfortunately for Peter he never found his way back to his brothers due to their all dieing in cannon.
Thanks for the review I hope to one day finish this series.
Review By [BerserkerNW
] • Date [8 Dec 10] • Rating [8 out of 10]
Review of chapter "In Which Silas Meets Harry" from KingDarius
i started reading this series a log time ago, then lost track of it until recently. overall it was pretty good, though i wasn't exactly happy with Xander dying, since im definately a xander fan at heart. ive never read nor watched anita blake but the story was still understandable though again, wasn't thrilled with the ending, as for the other crossovers: i haven't watched the last two seasons but i liked it, and it was an interesting take on how the alterans ascended. and as for firefly, i never watched the show though i did see the movie and i liked that, thought having her as inara an interesting choice. anyway, i hope you update soon.
Review By [KingDarius
] • Date [5 Oct 10] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "In Which Silas Meets Harry" from Crayshack
I am sort of curious as to what happend to Methos.
Review By [Crayshack
] • Date [8 Aug 10] • Not Rated