Large PrintHandheldAudioRating
using
 paypal
Twisting The Hellmouth Crossing Over Awards - Results
Rules for Challenges

Meeting the Dads: Horatio Caine

StoryReviewsStatisticsRelated StoriesTracking
Review of chapter "Meeting the Dads, Chapter 6: Horatio Caine" from Harry
Review:
Horatio was always a favorite of mine on CSI: Miami. And I can see that he and Buffy, along with Giles, got along very well. Now, lets see how things work out with the next name on the list.
Comments from author:
I'd probably hit Horatio in real life after a day, but as a character, he's a hoot...at least in the earlier seasons.
Review By [Harry] • Date [15 Dec 12] • Rating [10 out of 10]
Review of chapter "Meeting the Dads, Chapter 6: Horatio Caine" from serenityselena
Review:
another good person on the list ^_^
Comments from author:
Thanks. For most of the TV show, he makes me swoon. Last couple seasons, not so much.
Review By [serenityselena] • Date [26 Jan 11] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Meeting the Dads, Chapter 6: Horatio Caine" from BerserkerNW
Review:
Good story. I think I've read all of the 'Meeting the Dads' awhile ago, but didn't review. Rectifying that now. Starting here and then returning to #1.... Yeah. Anyway, this was a great read; very well written. Thanks for sharing!
Comments from author:
This was another one of my favorite dads. Kinda wanted to pout that he didn't win. Thanks again for all the reviews.
Review By [BerserkerNW] • Date [15 Sep 10] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Meeting the Dads, Chapter 6: Horatio Caine" from winnie
Review:
I like the way you are weaving the stories around the possible fathers.
Comments from author:
Thanks. Some dads were easier than others.
Review By [winnie] • Date [28 Oct 09] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Meeting the Dads, Chapter 6: Horatio Caine" from dragonfan
Review:
I have to admit that so far, H is one of the best candidates, with Gibbs coming in a very close second.

Thank you for saving Speed, although I personally have a major bitch with the writers over that one. That being of course that Speed isn't stupid and the only times we ever saw him careless with stuff was on the two occasions his gun malfunctioned. Once was enough. They should have killed him off some other way, not that I ever wanted him dead. *wanders off grumbling at stupid writers taking the easy way out*
Comments from author:
Tell me about it, some of the crap writers pull on their shows just pisses me off. 'It's better for ratings.' What a load! Sometimes, I think they just like to see their characters suffer as much as possible.
Review By [dragonfan] • Date [31 Aug 09] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Meeting the Dads, Chapter 6: Horatio Caine" from TwoBlackDragons
Review:
General Hammond
All of SG-1 including Sam, this story tells how she could be the "Father".
[http://www.tthfanfic.org/Story-17254/JadeAislin+Chance+to+Change.htm]

Sam Braun or Gil Grissom from CSI Vegas.

Methos or Duncan McCloud from Highlander.

I wouldn't mind multiple end stories from this fic!
Comments from author:
Not sure how to get around the sterility of the Immortals, and the Stargate crew is off limits for this challenge (but Musie is planning on writing a separate story for them), but the CSI guys could be interesting. I’ll have to watch the show to get a better idea about them.

The ending will be up to the reviewers. Be sure to vote!
Review By [TwoBlackDragons] • Date [22 Aug 09] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Meeting the Dads, Chapter 6: Horatio Caine" from djhardim
Review:
I just read this again - like visiting an old friend.

This incident is a disaster for the department. I wonder what the papers would say.

I wouldn't want to be in Speed's shoes when he goes before the review board.
Chances are that Speed won't be going out in the field anytime soon.
Comments from author:
Wonder what the lowest grunt work in the department is? Spraying down the morgue after autopsies? What probably *should* be his punishment is helping Calleigh out in Ballistics. Maybe then he'd learn the importance of cleaning his gun.
Review By [djhardim] • Date [12 Aug 09] • Rating [9 out of 10]
Review of chapter "Meeting the Dads, Chapter 6: Horatio Caine" from TouchoftheWind
Review:
Very good- I like this very much!
Comments from author:
Thanks. Glad you like the series so far.
Review By [TouchoftheWind] • Date [31 Jul 09] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Meeting the Dads, Chapter 6: Horatio Caine" from (Past Donor)KieriToews
Review:
Ok, I loved this one!!

Now I find myself pulling for Horatio Caine being the daddy. Thanks ever so *pouts*!

I was certain I wanted Mulder (or again, Alex Krycek) as Buffy's baby daddy ((ok, why on earth I used that term I'll never know seeing as I heartily dislike it!!))- but now I'm not so certain- because I now find myself intrigued by the dynamics between Buffy and Horatio. So thanks again for making me like this possibility... yeah, there was some sarcasm to be had *grin*.
Comments from author:
Oh, I'm heartbroken that I've upset you (stifle laugh). Yeah, my personal preference of Horatio may have tainted the story a bit for the readers.
Review By [(Past Donor)KieriToews] • Date [12 Jul 09] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Meeting the Dads, Chapter 6: Horatio Caine" from RedHeadReader
Review:
LET IT BE CAINE!! I love Horatio from CSI:Miami, and I think He'd make a great dad! My vote is for him to be the father (unless Jack O'Neill/Daniel Jackson/Tea'c is a candidate). And you don't even have to pair up Buffy and Horatio, cuz I 'm a Speedle/Caine shipper (thankyouthankyouthankyou Thank You btw, for saving Speed, I cried when he died, and stopped watching my marathon of CSI for a whole two days of mourning - freaked my parents out ;p).

RHR

PS. A list of fathers I thought of off the top of my head: Gibbs/Tony/Timothy McGee from NCIS (Timmy is a computer genious remember?? Gibbs is a great father figure and Tony would just be funny), James Bond (lots of samples from him lying around lol), one of the Ghostbusters, Michel Corvin from Underworld (before he turns into the Lycan/Vamp hybrid, maybe Wash saw the potential in his blood), Rick O'Connell/Ardeth from the Mummy, JD/Dr.Cox/The Janitor from Scrubs, and one of the Winchester Boys (or John Winchester/Bobby).
Comments from author:
I wouldn't mind using Giles for a 'ship, but only in the case where the dad is a complete waste of space - which I would have to wonder at the revewers' sanity if that happened. But I love Horatio too and think he'd be a good match for Buffy if he can accept the supernatural.

EDIT: There will be an NCIS chapter coming up as soon as I've put some distance between that and the reveal that Gibbs is Buffy's dad in another of my fics. I just get squicked at the idea of writing him as her dad and the father of her child at the same time - even though they are in separate stories.
Review By [RedHeadReader] • Date [11 Jul 09] • Rating [10 out of 10]
Review of chapter "Meeting the Dads, Chapter 6: Horatio Caine" from clarityfades
Review:
Great meeting! Loved how Buffy & Horatio met, loved his reaction to her looking for him. & I'm glad she didn't kill the criminal. Nice realizations about Angel, btw...I think that's an important step since she's potentially about to be a mommy. I'm glad she can look @ the past w/ a more mature POV. & I'm loving the father-figure vibe of Giles through all these...fantastic!
Comments from author:
I could never have Buffy kill a human being...I think. At least not using her Slayer powers. Never was much of an Angel fan so writing her getting over him was very easy. And it seems important that Buffy and Giles grow closer during this time, even if he end up having to share her with the baby's dad in the end. They deserve to be best friends.
Review By [clarityfades] • Date [27 Jun 09] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Meeting the Dads, Chapter 6: Horatio Caine" from Claddagh
Review:
Ok, I also have a couple of suggestions. How about:
Don from Numb3rs
Ian from Numb3rs
Eliott from Leverage
Mac from CSI New York
Comments from author:
Thanks for the suggestions.
Review By [Claddagh] • Date [24 Jun 09] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Meeting the Dads, Chapter 6: Horatio Caine" from Claddagh
Review:
Oh my gosh! You saved Speed! Ok, now you have my vote. I really, really, really want Horatio to be the Daddy.................Pretty Please??
Comments from author:
You don't have to convince me. It's the other reviewers that you have to work on.
Review By [Claddagh] • Date [24 Jun 09] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Meeting the Dads, Chapter 6: Horatio Caine" from meowfornow
Review:
Really really good. Much appreciated that you wrote this. Thanks for saving Tim too.
Comments from author:
Glad you enjoyed it. I had to save Speed, if only so I wouldn't have to 'watch' Horatio in that much pain again.
Review By [meowfornow] • Date [23 Jun 09] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Meeting the Dads, Chapter 6: Horatio Caine" from harcroft
Review:
another good potential father, i'm not sure if Horatio Caine or Fox Mulder would be the best option. I still kind of want to see Leo form Charmed, though.
Comments from author:
Not entirely sure how I'd manage it, but what would you think if I made it a pre-Piper Leo meeting? You know, that early stages where he's just around as the handyman but they haven't fallen in love yet? Or maybe when she was with Dan? That way if Leo is voted to be the dad (assuming I can figure out his story), it wouldn't cause problems for him and Piper. Email me with your thoughts.
Review By [harcroft] • Date [22 Jun 09] • Not Rated
Page: 1 of 3 next end
StoryReviewsStatisticsRelated StoriesTracking