Review of chapter "The Howling Dirge" from nerfherder
Review:
Still one of the best stories I have found on any of the Fic sites.
Review By [nerfherder] • Date [8 Apr 13] • Rating [10 out of 10]
Review of chapter "The Howling Dirge" from Thedruid
Review:
A real shame you only wrote a single short in this universe after this story. So you made Xander super-powered? Begin a crossover that is more his power level now. Heck, what if the intative manage to clone him? Or some magic user gets wise and banishes him to the X-men universe? Dawn, more aware of her status as the key ealier starts diminsion hopping, and Xander tags along?
:D
Review By [Thedruid] • Date [12 Oct 12] • Rating [10 out of 10]
Review of chapter "The Howling Dirge" from chrysanthemum
Review:
Awesome story! I liked that you didn't have Magneto's powers as the main point of the fic, and the interactions between the Scoobies were great. Thanks for a fantastic read!
Review By [chrysanthemum] • Date [23 Jul 12] • Rating [10 out of 10]
Review of chapter "The Howling Dirge" from nerfherder
Review:
All I can say is, W O W !!!!!!
Review By [nerfherder] • Date [3 Jun 12] • Rating [10 out of 10]
Review of chapter "The Howling Dirge" from mysticdreamer
Review:
Aww that's sad but at least we know Xander can still go in full on Magneto mode, good story sorry to see it end.
Review By [mysticdreamer] • Date [31 Jan 12] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "The Howling Dirge" from imortis
Review:
I've reread this four times now, and it never gets stale, please tell me your thinking about a sequel?
Review By [imortis] • Date [26 Jan 12] • Not Rated
Don't get it. A Xander who merely had Magneto's memories would have little effect on Sunnydale but a Xander with the university degree's you seemed to claim he has...and the attitude they were introduced with? Sunnydale should have changed. Dramatically.
If he truly cared about protecting his people and the only thing holding him back was Willow, why wasn't the first thing he did be to start counseling her? Or get enough money together to hire a professional psychologist or team of psychologists and counselors for all the Scoobies to hide that his true target was Willow?
Once she was stable he'd have been able to release his inner genius to increase the likelihood of everyone surviving living on a Hellmouth.
For that matter why, when the chips were down didn't he decide, "Sorry Willow, but the needs of the many... Please let her survive this."
As it was he wasn't prepared to protect Sunnydale's citizens, Willow, Giles, Jenny, or Buffy.
Wouldn't Magneto have been prepping to hand out combat armor? Communication devices? Surveillance over the town? What would the real Magneto have done? How much would Sunnydale have changed if he was really there?
Review of chapter "The Howling Dirge" from NuitTombee
Review:
Yet another read through and it's still a great story. So sad though. ;_;
-James
Review By [NuitTombee] • Date [7 Jan 12] • Rating [10 out of 10]
Review of chapter "The Howling Dirge" from Moontrap
Review:
This story was indescribably fantastic. Thank you for letting us read your work, and I can't wait to read either the sequel, or one of your other stories.
Sincerely
John
Review By [Moontrap] • Date [2 Sep 11] • Not Rated
I love your characterization of Magneto. However, I'm not too fond of Super!Xander and the way that all the girls fell in love with him. I think that Xander would have more trouble reconciling both sides of his personality than he has. Although that could be Erik's methods of repressing coming through.
Anyway, thank you for sharing this.
Review By [sevter] • Date [15 May 11] • Rating [7 out of 10]
Review of chapter "The Howling Dirge" from Freiheit
Review:
The story was great. I only know a bit of Magneto's history but i love how you go into his past and the reasons he did it. Always felt that he was giving the villain status when he only wanted to protect his people. Xander was a perfect fit. Always thought he needed more in the series. It will be one story that i will reread.
Review By [Freiheit] • Date [10 Apr 11] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "The Howling Dirge" from KingDarius
Review:
ive said it before, and ill say it again. you REALLY need to continue this series.
Review By [KingDarius] • Date [27 Mar 11] • Not Rated
Great story you blended the two series perfectly in my opinion. also liked how you had glory come earlier in the time line. i always wondered why they never had two big bad at one time that were going after everyone
Review By [kelvin] • Date [27 Mar 11] • Rating [10 out of 10]
Review of chapter "The Howling Dirge" from PhoenixFTW
Review:
Spectacular.
Review By [PhoenixFTW] • Date [13 Jan 11] • Not Rated