Large PrintHandheldAudioRating
Twisting The Hellmouth Crossing Over Awards - Results
Rules for Challenges

Sock Puppets

StoryReviewsStatisticsRelated StoriesTracking
Review of chapter "Let's Sort It Out" from (Past Donor)improvedpeanut
I like this story very much and agree with where everyone was sorted. Dawn and Luna friends? Fantastic, Luna is one of my favorite characters and the way the books made it seem she was treated in her house sounded very lonely.
You said something at the beginning about pairing requests? Can I still throw something out there?
Hermione/Fred(Weasley) for some reason I love them together and would love to read more fics with that pairing.

Can't wait to read more. :D
Review By [(Past Donor)improvedpeanut] • Date [5 Jul 11] • Rating [10 out of 10]
Review of chapter "Let's Sort It Out" from ChaosLady
I laughed my ass off when Buffy not only told Whistler off but Whistler said 'I told you so' to the Powers. I groaned when they lost their memories and everything went AU. I chuckled when BUFFY was sorted into Slytherin, especially the reason why. I can't wait to see where you go with this. Sign me up!
Review By [ChaosLady] • Date [4 Jul 11] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Let's Sort It Out" from Blackett
Interesting. I'm looking forward to more chapters.
Comments from author:
thank you, next one out soon
Review By [Blackett] • Date [2 Jul 11] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Let's Sort It Out" from Morgomir
Great story so far. Keep up the good work.
Comments from author:
thank you so much :)
Review By [Morgomir] • Date [2 Jul 11] • Rating [10 out of 10]
Review of chapter "Let's Sort It Out" from Cmiller
That was awesome. Does this mean you are going to add more sooner?

Also I could see the SAM transfers(Scoobs) pulling pranks on the Weasley twins or Marauders level.

I hope Xander, willow, Buffy, and Faith say "f-you to the gryffindor/slythern rivalry.
Comments from author:
yes, i will.. so thank you and please keep reading..
Review By [Cmiller] • Date [2 Jul 11] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Let's Sort It Out" from Meneldur
Very interesting. How did the Powers manage this? Is Joyce truly resurrected? Might others (Jenny, Tara) be resurrected later as well? I think the Scoobies should be getting some reward, not only for what they did, but also compensation for what was done to them. What happened to all the other Slayers? Brainwashed? Mind-wiped? Or simply allowed to drift off once they had no leaders/organization? In any case, once the Scoobies get back their memories (and they probably will, what with Willow's mojo) The Powers are going to have to find some way to reward/compensate them.
I think the sorting was rather accurate. I can easily see Faith and her 'boytoy' causing (more) havoc in Gryffindor. Dawn will be a moderating influence in Ravenclaw, probably, a bridge between Luna and the others. Interesting that Luna appears to possess some true sight, since she recognizes Dawn. Willow is excellent for Slytherin, though Buffy is only there because she's needed. Still, they'll shelter each other - Willow will use her Slytherin talents and supposed pureblood status to cover for Buffy, and Buffy will use her bluntness, assertiveness and strength to stand up for Willow when Willow wouldn't. I do hope they'll manage to make friends with Daphne and Tracey, who seem to be the only ones not overtly prejudiced/mean/evil in the House in their year. Fact is, they probably work in the same way Willow and Buffy will have to - Daphne provides cover for Tracey as the pureblood patron, and Tracey is a loyal and needed ally, considering how the inner politics of Slytherin probably work.
And I may be reading too much into this, but is there a hint to Willow's lesbianism in that she does not find harry attractive? And if so, who will she be with with? Will Tara return, or will Willow find another 'bad girl' (see Kennedy), probably from Slytherin?
Can't wait to see more of this.
Comments from author:
how did the powers manage this? well if the monks could alter everyone's memories, couldn't the powers do the same, plus more? I don't see bringing jenny back cuz the Powers have put Joyce with Giles, and that would just cause unnecessary conflict.
I'm glad you caught onto Buffy's placement... now just think, was the hat heeding the Powers That Be there, or does he truly think she will do the most good there...
I've never seen Faith and Gryffindor, but when i pulled that from the hat, i thought it could work and be different. and Luna... well i love Luna :D ...
Daphne... well, you'll see more of her in the next chapter, perhaps get an idea of what she's like...
I do have a pairing in my for Willow... :) thats all i'm saying, thanks for readig
Review By [Meneldur] • Date [2 Jul 11] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Let's Sort It Out" from FireWolfe
I sort of agree with the last review. Only when you think about it Buffy is very cunning. She is often underestimated by her enemies. I can easily see her in the house that values ambision and power. Willow well that is a no brainer given her past. Faith I could see as a Lion because of her path to redemption. I would have made Xander a badger. I agree with Dawn placement. I would have loved to see Cordy and Oz but as its the core group I love it. Bonus points for bringing back Joyce. Love to see Tara too. Anywat nice fic so far. I can't wait to see the pairings. Though I hope its a bit of a surprise as long as its not slash is should be fun. Well other then Willow because I would love to see her with Tara again oddly I love that match. Well Love her and Oz too.
Comments from author:
thanks for reading... at the beginning i said i picked everyone out of a hat... i had chosen before like years ago and truthfully, Faith is the only one who was placed elsewhere then where i originally had her, weird how it worked out...
AS for Xander.. while i did find him quite Loyal in that sense, you only need to think about what he would do when he was upset or hurt by his friends.. he would find a way to hurt them back and i never thought that was very hufflepuff-y...
Just keep reading, who knows what will keep happening :)
Review By [FireWolfe] • Date [2 Jul 11] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Let's Sort It Out" from ChiVayne
I agree with where you sorted most of the Scoobies, but Buffy never struck me as ambitious. Some cunning surely but I would have pegged her as a Gryffindor. Or should I be reading more into the hat's 'where you would do the most good'?
Comments from author:
EXACTLY!!!! remember.. the hat knows more then it lets on, and it DID say where you would do the most good... hmmmm
Review By [ChiVayne] • Date [1 Jul 11] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Let's Sort It Out" from Wormbait
Nice story you have going on here, I like the way you brought them into the Wizarding World, something I havn't seen before. Although when then really figure out what happened Whistler is going to wish Buffy only took his ribcage for a hat. :)

I even gave a little cheer with the first appearence of Draco as it seemed he was going to be the nasty git we all know him to be, a truely rare thing in fanfics. But then you had him be all nice and smiley with Dawn, which has me worried he's going to be a closet white hat.

And then there's Luna, one of my favorite HP characters (along with Tonks, Remus and Hermione), any fic only gets better with liberal doses of Luna thrown in. :)

Well done and thanks for sharing, I look forward to seeing where you take things.
Comments from author:
Remember, he knows nothing about Dawn... he just sees, a perhaps pretty girl there...
thanks for liking and thanks for reading...
Review By [Wormbait] • Date [1 Jul 11] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Let's Sort It Out" from mokahi
Intriguing premise. Your method of bringing the Sunnydale gang to Hogwarts is quite unique. I look forward to seeing how it all plays out.
Comments from author:
thank you for reading and i hope you keep reading it
Review By [mokahi] • Date [1 Jul 11] • Rating [10 out of 10]
Review of chapter "Let's Sort It Out" from Fantasymania
Wow. Buffy in the house of the snakes. Cool!
Comments from author:
thank you! and thank you for reading!
Review By [Fantasymania] • Date [1 Jul 11] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Let's Sort It Out" from Hanzo
♫♥I look forward to reading what happens next in your story♥♪
Comments from author:
thank you for reading :)
Review By [Hanzo] • Date [1 Jul 11] • Rating [10 out of 10]
Review of chapter "Seeing is Not Believing" from Cmiller
Are you going to add more to this soon?
Comments from author:
yes.. soon :D
Review By [Cmiller] • Date [29 Dec 10] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Seeing is Not Believing" from LIGHThearted
This is so good! I almost felt like crying when Buffy had to say goodbye to her mom... I'm really looking forward to seeing how they deal with their slayerness, strength and etc. since they don't know what they are. oh and will Buffy take Harry's place on the team? can't wait for an update!
Review By [LIGHThearted] • Date [30 Mar 10] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "The Normal Life" from Kremer
I *hope* many changes will be explained sometime soon. You've skipped over A LOT!
So far, I'm still confused...

So every Scooby but Dawn regressed at least 3 years (and Dawn only 1)?
If both Buffy and Faith are still Slayers they haven't accidentally crushed doorknobs, glasses, or broken anything because they don't know their own strength yet?
Is Willow now strictly limited to a wand-wizard? No "thicken" anymore?
Do any of them have wands? (nothing mentioned so far)
What happened to the dozens/hundreds of other Slayers in the world? No more demons or Hellmouths anywhere anymore?
What about the destroyed Council headquarters and the massive amounts of monetary (and other) assets they would have built up around the world over many centuries? All gone now? No more New Council or Watchers to support all the newly created Slayers?

See what I mean? It's like the story suddenly jumped into a totally AU and completely and totally ignored everything else, even for the reader...
Comments from author:
i seriously thought i had replied to this... oh a year ago... so my apologies... but there's a reason everything completely skipped and you're going wtf????
Remember Season 5 of Buffy when Dawn was introduced, remember how, for a little while we were all going, huh? who is this girl and why is she Buffy's sister and why is everyone acting like this is normal and she's been there all along... was there some kind of spell?
hopefully now that i've returned to this, everything will become clear... but are you confused??? good
Review By [Kremer] • Date [30 Mar 10] • Rating [7 out of 10]
Page: 1 of 2 next end
StoryReviewsStatisticsRelated StoriesTracking