Another one I'd be quite interested to see more of, should you have time or inspiration to continue.
Keep the good work, regardless of what it's on.

amusewithaview: Re - Aliens among us , I have just discovered this story & am loving it’s a great mix of crossovers add to the BtVs Universe , I hope your Muse will bring you back to update this story soon .

Awesome story idea! Looking forward to more!

Intriguing choices to a popular premise. Although it might be a fun sideline for Giles to continue drilling Buffy in French so that she at least keeps something useful from her persona, despite it being a generic costume. Y'know, something to stop those memories fading. Just needs to be an offhand comment - probably a Xander one, or maybe Willow becoming concerned that Buffy's beating her in something...

Cordelia is going to be interesting. And Jonathon as Superman'll be a fascinating difference - he might try to improve himself, but only so he can help others...

Great work, more please.

definitely like!

Amazing job so far please keep updating I'm really looking forward to what happens

I like the idea of Jonathan's eyes being opened to what's really going on in Sunnydale so much sooner than in canon, and the idea that his experiences as Superman on Halloween may lead him in a much more constructive direction (I hope) than his 4th-season "Superstar" spell. Having been the real thing -- a real hero, truly motivated only by concern for others -- for even one night, I hope he'll be able to turn his talents to less selfish ends.

Nice work!

Like the work on this chapter, I hope you'll post more soon.

-When will you show what is going on with Cordelia?

Next chapter. The first chappie was all three of the Halloween-changed protagonists, and after that it's on rotation: Cordy, Xander, Jonathon. I'm planning about ten chapters for this first story so there'll be two more for Cordy's POV.

OMG you did smthg with Jonathon! That's so cool! Most people just stick him in the background if they do anything with him at all. Also, loved the "can't unsee" bit and the getting what you always wanted but not being able to enjoy b/c of the price. Can't wait to see where you go with the rest. Like Cordelia. I'm totally curious what happened to her.

Good that it wasn't Andrew, that would have been too over-done. I was afraid that the Superman dressed character would be a liability to the story, but this chapter shows that you might be able to handle it.
If Jonathon also only has memories, then you really need to have a good explanation if Cordy is still blue.

Like. Great way to go. Keep up the good work.

cool

I like it. It seems different from the same old YAHF story. Probably because it seems a little newer with the Avatar-ness and newer Spock-ness. Plus, he just had Spock's memories instead of suddenly being part vulcan as has been done several times.

I'd definitely like to read more.

If they all end up keeping some of their powers, then it would prove useful.

I presume that Jonathan would have the power levels from Lois and Clark or Smallville? DC comics are too exaggerated.

Buffy keeping the lifeskills of a noblewoman would be useful. Perhaps the language skills including Latin along with how to act around nobility?

Of course, Xander is very useful. Perhaps taking over Moloch's lair would make things easier for his projects.

Fascinating.

What? Someone had to say it! Look forward to more.