Review of chapter "Withering" from aerialla
I thought this was beautifully done and I can't believe that no one has reviewed it by now. I thought it perfect and very fitting in with the movie. Many people forget that Peter Jackson was doing his own little bit of fan fiction in the movie when he made changes that were not in the book. Haldir for one was not supposed to be at Helm's Deep either and he was and was killed. In the books he is not talked about much and it was presumed that he lived a long life.
Review By [aerialla
] • Date [19 Aug 07] • Rating [10 out of 10]