HUh, not really into Supernatural, but I'd thought I'd give this a try. Pretty good. In fact, I really think you write Dawn very well, and It's a shame that you have some many stories just left unfinished. Not like I have room to cast stones, but still, it truly is a shame. Well, thanks for writing this, bye for now.
Review By [deathgeonous] • Date [22 Aug 11] • Not Rated
I find it interesting that you chose to make Dawn Connor's surrogate mom when most writers pair them up romantically. I like the way you are blending the two universes and explaining Dawn's key-ness. Can't wait to read more.
Review By [GACTsevil] • Date [23 May 11] • Not Rated
You start from an absolutely original concept, at least to me, such that I'm surprised I've not seen it before. It makes so much sense that a possible side effect to Buffy's death would be the memory magic falling apart.
I do think that Dawn is reacting much older than her age, in canon she was 14? at this point and fairly helpless. If we assume her stories about working with Tara are true, coupled with the halloween memories (tho not sure how that would work since she wasn't actually in existence when the spell happened), then the older behavior begins to be a bit more plausible.
I'm not as familiar with SPN canon, but I think you've done a really good job easing her into that universe. And I love the twist of her happening upon and saving Connor, then naming him Connor too. It brings up so many possibilities should she ever encounter her home universe again. I'm intrigued by the dreams, the floating city and forests below make me think of the Nox in Stargate SG1 but then thats my particular background, for all I know its from an anime or something. No matter, the dreams are interesting.
I look forward to seeing where this goes. The writing for Dawn in a lot of stories is hit or miss for me, with a lot of miss, but I like what you've done with her.
Review By [kaleecat] • Date [22 May 11] • Not Rated
Ironic that she is raising Angel's son, after her experiences with Angelus. I like the 'Dawn background' pre spell ie memories and all that. Makes sense, same with the language prep. (I still love her dismayed reaction in S7 to translating Turkish, then "there's a translation?... ok, I'm over it" Good idea on the journals, but she should get a PC or laptop & put them on documents (passworded of course, with backups). Easier on the hand. Great setup, nicely woven into the SPN background now. Hm, if you want to be really evil (and you know you do!) at some point, a demon might pick Buffy's body as a perfect one to inhabit, since it's "empty". Maybe Meg? There was that ep where she left, came back with one that was brain dead or something, to keep Sam happy. Much later, gotta wonder how Castiel & company would react to her. He'd be sure to 'see' her for what she was (whatever that is). Not to mention if she runs into Lenore -the Tara lookalike (ie Amber Benson 'good' vampire). Ouch. I have to feel sorry for Angel on this. Hm, he might still end up running W&H if they promise him to use their resources to find Connor (ie as the hook to get him in). And imagine if they DID ... just a thought for future stories.
Review By [AllenPitt] • Date [21 May 11] • Not Rated
An interesting story problem for Dawn. The world that she is in is dangerous to her. But when isn't it. I suppose she likes the fact that daily life is less interrupted by the supernatural and she might only have to actively participate during "Apocalypse" season.
Review By [VillageOrchid] • Date [21 May 11] • Not Rated
WooHoo! I'm so excited that you updated so soon!! And this chapter, like the rest, was just excellent! I'm continuing to love your Dawn and her 'voice' in this. She's so.. practical, thinks so calmly/logically about everything. I love how nothing seems to faze her... At least not yet.
The surprises with Dawn already meeting Bobby and Pam along with Pastor Jim last chapter was just brilliant too... I never thought she would meet so many SN people so soon... I love it though =) I also loved Dawn first meeting with Bobby and that Pam knows 'what' she is.. well maybe not the Key part, but that she's not entirely human and that she's from another dimension. Pam figuring out and telling Dawn that Connor's a dhampir was also awesome. I was wondering how Dawn would find out and at least she now knows way before Connor's starts really growing.
Very cool too that Dawn's going to be living with Pam and helping hunters out with translating. Both ideas are brilliant and I can't wait to see Dawn working the research :) Also with them living with Pam Connor won't (along with Dawn) have to hide their more unique talents.
Great job on Dawn's backstory. I find myself fascinated by the parts about Tara and Jenny and them teaching her so much about magic, languages, etc... Adds more depth to her character.
Anyway, thanks bunches for the new chapter! I loved it to bits and I seriously can't wait to read more!!!
Review By [LeaFairy] • Date [20 May 11] • Rating [10 out of 10]
I'm still really enjoying this, though it's odd to think that your Dawn is only 15 or 16, when she seems more like someone in their early twenties (and a mature twenty-year-old at that). I can see circumstances making her grow up fast, but I hope we get to see flashes of Dawn being a teen, too.
Review By [littleoldme] • Date [20 May 11] • Not Rated
These first two chapters have been so utterly amazing!! Your Dawn is simply incredible. I really like how resourceful and mature she is... She's pretty damn sneaky and crafty with all her half-truths too :) I also love all the twists that have happened so far-- starting with the consequences of Buffy's death and Dawn being basically erased from everyone's memories, and then her running into the situation with Connor being taken by Holtz, following them through the portal and then her killing Holtz and keeping Connor (I freaking LOVE by the way that Connor's going to have a loving parent and that Holtz is dead!!), and then her eventually ending up in the Supernatural world and meeting Pastor Jim-- All of it is made of so much awesomeness!!! I really like the whole Carmen Sandiego thing as well. Very cool and definitely convenient for Dawn and her new lifestyle :-)
I also love how detailed both chapters are. I really love all the descriptions and action and the way you write Dawn and her thoughts/feelings. All of it is really well written and it has me very much intrigued for what's going happen next with Dawn and Connor.
Anyway, this story has to be one of the most interesting I've read in awhile and I very much look forward to reading more! Thanks so much for writing!!!
Comments from author:
Thanks for the review. Yeah, I think everybody wants Connor to have a better childhood.
Review By [LeaFairy] • Date [18 May 11] • Rating [10 out of 10]
Ok, so whether or not there was a supernatural event at Hemery, the Buffy in the institution is nuts, then? Too bad. Hm, I wonder if a DNA test would show they're related. Just a thought, it's not going to happen of course. Damn, Dawn is a great liar. Almost scarily so. The Carmen thing is great for setting it all up. There IS a Sunnyvale California but what the heck. Just say this dimension is different. In this one, Dawn's ability with languages & knowing about the supernatural could make her enormously valuable to hunters. Like that guy at the Roadhouse only more so. And it'll likely be years before Connor is old enough for people to notice he's inhumanly strong & tough (on Angel a pickup truck rammed him & he was ok) --hm, and other demons will probably be looking for him eventually, too. Floating cities--Avatar? ... I suppose the big question now is when this is, in the SPN timeline. Before the first episode?
Comments from author:
Thanks for the review. I'll admit, I'm a bit surprised to see you over here rather than over at ffn.
Yeah, this is the Buffy from that episode in Season 6 who's completely insane and institutionalized.
Nope, not Avatar. Think less movie, more tv show. I'm going to be adding to the disclaimer in Chapter 4, so it should become clearer then. I don't want to say anything else and spoil it.
Alright, so in the SPN timeline this is about a year before Sam ran off to go to College, so roughly five years before the pilot. Dawn is currently on the verge of turning fifteen (although her forgeries say that she's 16) and is about six years younger than Dean and two years younger than Sam.
Review By [AllenPitt] • Date [7 May 11] • Not Rated