Large PrintHandheldAudioRating
Twisting The Hellmouth Crossing Over Awards - Results
Rules for Challenges

Noah Puckerman

StoryReviewsStatisticsRelated StoriesTracking
Review of chapter "Brave New World - Or You Know..." from calikocat
Pretty interesting...can't wait to see Puck's reaction to Giles' Ripper side since he's already scared of the librarian. Tracking now.
Comments from author:
Thank you =) Giles must be one of my favorite BtVS characters, but he's very difficult to write, so I can't promise he will be around a lot. I find it much easier to get into the heads of the younger characters, so you will defenitely see more of them. Also a new character is introduced in a few chapters, one who didn't get their due on the show (I think). So keep your peepers open! =)
Review By [calikocat] • Date [15 Apr 13] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Brave New World - Or You Know..." from banditdoz
Wow fantastic I really Love this story and this is the only glee cross over I have been Impressed with Thanks for writing and good luck I cant wait to see how Puck deals with Ford and the twilight club ;D
Comments from author:
Thank you =) That is a great compliment and I will try to stay humble ;P But just so you don't get very disappointed with the following chapters I will have to tell you that Puck will not have a lot to do with the actual fighting part of things just yet. He has more important things on his mind.
Review By [banditdoz] • Date [16 Feb 13] • Rating [10 out of 10]
Review of chapter "Brave New World - Or You Know..." from (Current Donor)Katrina
So far it's very enjoyable, thank you.
Comments from author:
Thank you for reading =)
Review By [(Current Donor)Katrina] • Date [15 Feb 13] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "The Morning After (I Was Almost Killed)" from BluLadyK
I'm really a fan of this story! A lot of the Glee stories aren't as good and I end up disappointed when I'm done reading, but this is a great story that sticks with the spirit of all of the characters.

I can't wait for the next installment!
Comments from author:
Wow! Thank you for that amazing compliment =D I can't say how happy it made me!

The next chapter will probably be a while, since it seems that I have come to a slight wall that needs to be climbed, or knocked down, or something before I can keep writing. Don't worry though... it's coming =)

Thanks again! /Pyret
Review By [BluLadyK] • Date [6 May 12] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "The Morning After (I Was Almost Killed)" from RevDorothyL
"Puck stared at her for a long time, wondering how she could act like everything was normal and that the world as he knew it hadn’t come to a terrifying end just a few hours ago."

Loved the way this chapter opened up Puck's worldview in so many ways (many of which, like the realization that Willow had become a very accomplished and believable liar,when it came to covering for Slaying-related injuries, he might be more comfortable skipping).

But now that his eyes are opened, there's no going back for Puck!
Comments from author:
Nope, no going back... but is there ever? I mean... everyone who found out about Vamps and other uglies, ended up fighting the good fight in one way or another.. well.. maybe not Oz, but he had issues of his own to deal with.

Let's just say that I have big plans for Puck... he's not going to have an easy time at all.

Thanks for your review! =D
Review By [RevDorothyL] • Date [10 Apr 12] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "The Morning After (I Was Almost Killed)" from falsegod
totally baddass but really he just admitted he was gay had a semi hookup with a guy and you throw him headfirst a vagina what the fuck?
Comments from author:
You should take a closer look at chapter 6 "Let's Get Together - Violently". But for all our sakes, I'll tell you here:

""And he realized, as he lay there underneath another guy, that he liked the feel of it. But that didn’t make him gay, right? No, definitely not, he thought as he remembered how amazing it felt to have Santana moaning under him.""

There is such a creature as Bisexuality, and I think it's narrowminded to think that just because you enjoy the company of men you can't enjoy women, and vice versa.

Puck is a "sex-shark"... of course he would go after Cordelia, even if he starts out not liking her very much. This will not become a Puck/Cordelia story, however. As it stands now there will be no surprise pairings for any longer period of time.

Did you know that if a shark stops moving, it dies?

Thanks for you review, and please come again. =)

Review By [falsegod] • Date [9 Apr 12] • Rating [8 out of 10]
Review of chapter "Thriller (But Without the Zombies)" from Blackett
need more...soonish:)
Comments from author:
You know.. I know this is meant to be some kind of compliment, but I really do HATE this kind of review. The next chapter will be posted when it's posted, not a second sooner.

I do hope that you will continue to read and enjoy this story though.

Thanks /Pyret
Review By [Blackett] • Date [11 Mar 12] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Thriller (But Without the Zombies)" from foaminbones
Nice. Waiting. Of so patiently for the next chapter
Comments from author:
Thank you for your review =)

I don't know when the next chapter will be posted. I'm working from the promise I made a few chapters ago "Finish a chapter - Post a chapter" which means that when I finish chapter 11, I will be posting chapter 8. I really hope you keep reading and ejoying my story! =)

Review By [foaminbones] • Date [24 Feb 12] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Let's Get Together - Violently" from musiclover
interesting story good set up but to me seems inconsitent i get the way the act from chapter to chapter is what may be real reactions but yah kinda messing up the flow some ways i mean one chapter willow looks to get that puck kinda wanted kurt but the two chapters down shes acting like its some new revelation well thats what i remember anyway i didnt reread the other chapters of the story
Comments from author:
Thank you for your review. Have you thought about checking the spelling before posting? And maybe you've heard about punctuation? It's this really cool thing that makes text readable.

To answer your concerns; I try very hard to keep the characters in character, and that means some inconsistencies because people react differently to situations depending on their mood, and who says/does something, and so on.

Willow didn't know anything about Puck maybe wanting Kurt untill they were in the computer lab and he made her swear not to tell anyone. Before that she only knew that Puck used to bully Kurt and was kind of sorry about it. Maybe you were thinking about the scene in "Angry All the Time" where Xander ask Puck if he were gay, but that was just a general question, and nothing specific about Kurt. They were talking about Kurt just before, so I understand the confusion. My betas didn't have any trouble with it though.

Thanks again for your review, and Merry Christmas!
Review By [musiclover] • Date [24 Dec 11] • Rating [7 out of 10]
Review of chapter "Let's Get Together - Violently" from spacey
Wow, puck, u prick!
Comments from author:
Yes, he is a prick in some ways... are we surprised? =P
Review By [spacey] • Date [23 Dec 11] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Angry All the Time" from mousemt
Nice. I like the premise better than I thought I would, and your characterizations are great.
Comments from author:
Thank you =) I'm glad the characters makes sense to someone other than me =P
Review By [mousemt] • Date [10 Dec 11] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Angry All the Time" from Sinangeled
Awesome chapter! I really like Buffy and Puck being friends, but not anything more. It's nice :)
Comments from author:
Thank you =) I wasn't sure if I would be able to post anything this week, but then I finished ch9 yesterday and I thought 'what the hay' =P
Yeah, I can't see Puck and Buffy being more than friends, I don't know why. Maybe because Buffy is so in love with Angel, and Puck... I don't really know about him.. he's a sex-shark, right? hehe And I think Buffy is too nice for him. Puck needs girls like Quinn, Lauren or maybe Cordelia... but we all know who he really loves, don't we? ;P (that would be Kurt)
Review By [Sinangeled] • Date [10 Dec 11] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Back To School" from LLN
this is cool, puck is one of my fav characters, so is Kurt going to make an appearance?
would love to see how Kurt and Queen C would react to each other.

keep writing!!!

Comments from author:
Sorry to disappoint you LLN but as of right now I have no plans of bringing Kurt into this story more than he already is. He will stay in the back of Puck's mind and send him the occational e-mail and FB message, which will also remain mysterious since they won't let me read them...

But maybe Kurt will hop on a plane and visit... I can't always controle what the characters do when I'm not looking.

So to sum up.. my "No" is not written in stone. =P

And Kurt and Cordelia in the same room is either a match made in heaven or potentially the worst disaster Sunnydale has ever seen. It could be very interesting =P
Review By [LLN] • Date [2 Dec 11] • Rating [9 out of 10]
Review of chapter "Back To School" from MissE
Nice chapter. Liked how Puck picked up on Larry's closeted state and his outsider's view of the school population.
Comments from author:
Thank you =) I figured Puck would be the kind of person who was secretly very observant and since he was one of the top dogs at McKinley he would be very consious of the social heirarky at his new school. So it only made sense for him to notice those things. Larry will have an important role in a later chapter so I needed the set-up =P stay tuned!
Review By [MissE] • Date [1 Dec 11] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Back To School" from Sinangeled
I totally loved this chapter! your characterization is amazing!
Comments from author:
Thank you! I'm relieved that someone, other than me, thinks it makes sense =P Puck comes very easy to me but Giles... geesh.. who knew he would be the tricky one? He's such a know-it-all, and since we haven't gotten to the point in the show where he lets Buffy run free; he's pretty up-tight and never goes in the direction I want.

Sorry... I'm done bitching...

Thank you again for the review! =)
Review By [Sinangeled] • Date [1 Dec 11] • Not Rated
Page: 1 of 2 next end
StoryReviewsStatisticsRelated StoriesTracking