Review of chapter "Buffy XI - Changing of the Guard" from Thedruid
Review:
Nice plot so far. I'm actually hoping Faith and Buffy can redeem the Sith and Jedi.
Comments from author:
Thanks! I'm glad you're enjoying it. With regard for Buffy and Faith 'redeeming' both Jedi and Sith... I don't think my story will have that much of an impact on the Star Wars universe. I suppose I intend for this story to take place alongside the events of the existing Star Wars timeline, which will continue onward towards the eventual rise of the Galactic Empire and it's downfall at the hands of the Rebel Alliance one day.
None of that means, however, that this tale of Buffy and Faith won't have a satisfying, definite conclusion, but I intend for it to be an addition to the existing mythos of both series, and not rewriting either one (unless you count the Buffy comics, which I personally don't).
Thank you again for your review, and I hope you continue to enjoy the story! ^_^
Review By [Thedruid] • Date [15 May 13] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Buffy XI - Changing of the Guard" from BHRamsay
Review:
Aewsome chapter Buffy is darkening nicely and believeably-- thanks for sharing
Comments from author:
Thank you very much! I'm very glad that Buffy's slide to the Dark Side seems credible. I honestly wasn't sure how I was going to pull it off at first. There's an old saying: 'The road to Hell is paved with good intentions.' Pretty much every fallen hero in every story ever told started off wanting to do what seemed right at the time. If/when Buffy's personality becomes even darker, I hope you find it just as believable.
Review By [BHRamsay] • Date [7 May 13] • Rating [9 out of 10]
Review of chapter "Buffy XI - Changing of the Guard" from MrPowell
Review:
Shouldn't that be Lady Sunhome? I'm pretty sure that tradition or not, Buffy wouldn't use the masculine. It's good to see more of this
Comments from author:
I thought about having her go by 'Lady Sunhome,' but in my experience with the games, 'Lord' is a gender-neutral title that is used regularly by both male and female Sith. Besides, Lord sounds more intimidating than Lady, at least to my mind's ear.
I hope you like the chapter! Stay tuned for more!
Review By [MrPowell] • Date [7 May 13] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Buffy XI - Changing of the Guard" from Sithspit
Review:
Yay, you're back! It HAS been a long while.
Comments from author:
Indeed, it has. Hopefully there won't be any really long delays anymore, but alas, nothing is certain.
Review By [Sithspit] • Date [7 May 13] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Buffy XI - Changing of the Guard" from Muadzin
Review:
Ominous voice - It is still alive! - end ominous voice
And in a single chapter my favorite Slayer has lesbian/alien sex, engages in some casual killing and takes another step down the Dark Side. Busy, busy, busy!
I'm glad to see this story ain't dead yet. Here's to hoping the next chapter won't take as long. Then again, I'm not allowed to complain, doing some major procrastinating on my own story.
Comments from author:
Heh. Yes, this story is far from dead. I certainly hope that the next chapter will be up in a shorter span of time, but I make no promises. I wish you all the best of luck with working on your own story.
Review of chapter "Buffy XI - Changing of the Guard" from grd
Review:
Enjoying Buffy's growth in the force. Hope she keeps on remembering to do good despite the evil around her. She will show them a side to the Force ignored by the Sith who blindly follow anger, hate, and fear.
Eager to see how Faith is doing.
Comments from author:
Never fear, my friend. Buffy will always be a shade of gray, no matter how far she succumbs. She's no Evil Overlord or anything of the sort, but she is a warrior in the company of those who are guiding her down a dark path.
I'll try to post Faith XI as soon as I can. Stay tuned!
Review By [grd] • Date [6 May 13] • Rating [10 out of 10]
Review of chapter "Buffy XI - Changing of the Guard" from Cmiller
Review:
dude.... that was great.
Question when will you have more of your Willow in the HP past story??
Comments from author:
Hey there! I'm glad you liked the chapter.
As to when I will be updating The Better Part of Valor... My part as the main author for that story is over, I think. I have had it listed for some time that I am seeking a co-author who can bring a level of enthusiasm to the story that I simply do not possess. I would love to remain on in an editorial and advisory capacity, but the actual writing would be left to someone else (in my ideal future).
Thank you for your interest in my stories, and best wishes!
Review of chapter "Faith X - Descent" from Veracity
Review:
This has been a great story so far. I assumed it was going to be Faith who was the Sith but I'm glad that it was Buffy instead! There are far too many stories with Buffy being the hero and its a nice change of pace for Faith. Still coming into this story its a hard notion to believe that Buffy would be on the bad side, but you have written the subtle transformation and following descent so well that it is hard to believe she was anything but. Also, the switching POVs between chapters is brilliant as it keeps the pacing of the story so that there is never a dull moment.
I'd also like to offer a bit of constructive criticism if I may. Regarding the Buffy/Faith interludes I felt the dialogue was a bit wooden, almost robotic, but strangely it didn't feel like that anywhere else in the story. I'm also curious about Buffy in general as it seems Faith has more of an internal monologue so we can understand her POV better where with Buffy it seems she is a bit more hidden from our prying eyes. Thinking about it now this could actually just be a plot device to add more of a clashing between Jedi/Sith ideals within the main protagonists.
Anyways, I love this story its well written and a good read. Not sure if you plan to continue but if you are then there better be a Buffy and Faith lightsaber duel! Either way thank you so much for this enjoyable read and I look forward to possible future writings.
Comments from author:
Hi there!
Thank you very much for your kind words, and for your constructive feedback. You are not the first to point out to me that I need to show more of what's going on inside of Buffy's head, and I intend to take that advice to heart when I continue this story. I cannot, however, give you a date for when the next chapter will be posted. My Muse has been uncooperative for quite a while, unfortunately, but I definitely want to give this story a proper wrap-up and ending.
As for the dialog in the interludes seeming a bit stilted or robotic, I intended it to come off that way. They are dreaming, and dreams are surreal things. I tried to emulate the tone set in the opening scene of the episode 'This Year's Girl' in which Buffy and Faith are in a bedroom together and speaking cryptically in near-monotone as they make the bed. I am sorry if it feels awkward to read, but that was to some extent the intended effect.
Thank you again for your feedback, and stay tuned! ^_^
Review By [Veracity] • Date [2 May 13] • Rating [8 out of 10]
Review of chapter "Faith X - Descent" from betascud
Review:
I didn't play SWTOR MMO, but the parallelism here is stagerring. Go on, please...
Comments from author:
I am glad you are enjoying the story. I will try my best to update at least once a week. I can't promise anything, of course, but I will try my best.
Review By [betascud] • Date [20 Jan 13] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Faith X - Descent" from Muadzin
Review:
To be honest this felt a little....., hurried? Like you were trying to cram too many things into a single (short) chapter. An epic story, like the death of a Jedi master that Faith loved, deserves to take its time. It deserved a little Dragonball Z treatment, and not the 20 episodes long power ups, cause they sucked, but at least a battle and a good lead up journey towards that battle that takes its sweet time. Now I'm feeling more like how come Hutt credits are fake credits as opposed to OMG! Faith's master and beloved tutor died! It didn't really feel as his crowning moment of awesome.
Not saying it sucked, but it could have been better.
Comments from author:
I am so sorry to disappoint. I've never written off a character in this way before, so this is new territory for me. If I ever have to do something like this again, I'll try to make it last longer and feel more significant. If you have any specific ideas on how it could have been improved, I would love to hear your thoughts.
Thank you for being honest with constructive criticism. It hurts a bit to know that I let you down, but it will hopefully help me to grow as a writer. I sincerely hope that the rest of the story is as good as you want it to be.
Review By [Muadzin] • Date [20 Jan 13] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Faith X - Descent" from DarthPayne
Review:
Well, that was a surprising ending...
Comments from author:
What can I say? Nothing lasts forever.
Review By [DarthPayne] • Date [19 Jan 13] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Buffy X - Power Overwhelming" from DarthTenebrus
Review:
Ha ha ha ha ha ha........
Your Muse is STRONG with the Dark Side...a powerful Sith she will become. Henceforth, she will be known as Darth ...
...Sumar.
Buffy is starting to really scare me now...we'll done.
Comments from author:
I'm glad you're enjoying the story, but I have no reason to call Buffy anything resembling 'Sumar.' This is not another Star Wars fanfic with Buffy as Empress Sumar. 'Faith in the Force,' I think it was called. I hope you continue to enjoy my story, but I do hope you will take it on its own and not expect me to use the same ideas as other authors.
Review By [DarthTenebrus] • Date [17 Jan 13] • Rating [10 out of 10]
Review of chapter "Buffy X - Power Overwhelming" from Muadzin
Review:
Hmm, I wonder if Faith will still like Buffy once they finally do meet up again. She continues to change for the worse with each chapter.
As for the e-cookie, power overwhelming came from the Protoss Archon from Starcraft, one of the best strategy games evah!
I'll take my e-cookie, as long as Buffy will be the one who delivers it. She's my favorite flavor. ;)
Comments from author:
Will Faith still like Buffy? I doubt it. Buffy's current philosophy seems to be a bit too close to 'want, take, have.' Faith does not want to see her old self in Buffy, but I can't imagine any anger over it. Sadness, definitely, and a desire to help. We will see how things turn out.
With regards to your e-cookie, I don't think you can have a Buffy-flavored pastry. She is only ever cookie dough, remember? ;-)
Review By [Muadzin] • Date [16 Jan 13] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Buffy X - Power Overwhelming" from grd
Review:
I hope Buffy's real test was to not abandon Dalen. Defeating the creature was secondary.
Comments from author:
Alas, I would say that the test was to determine how much power in the Dark Side that Buffy possessed. Not only that, but her willingness to use it.
The people who built these ruins were not very nice at all. They were pretty much the opposite of nice. All of the niceness-making factories on all of their worlds were burned to the ground before they could ever be built, and the nice people who came up with the idea to spread niceness around were summarily executed.
They were a people who valued things that were not nice. The Dark Side is not a nice thing. They liked the Dark Side. A lot.
And, I see the bell is about to ring. Your homework, good sir or madam: construct a diorama that depicts the perpetual struggle between the Forces of Nice and the Legions of Not-Nice.
Review By [grd] • Date [16 Jan 13] • Rating [10 out of 10]
Review of chapter "Buffy X - Power Overwhelming" from DarthPayne
Review:
So, i'm guessing that Buffy will be an Inquisitor due to that storm?
Comments from author:
I'm not saying that Buffy or Faith have to fit into any of the classes from the game. The MMO just gives them a setting to have the story take place in. Buffy is a Sith, Faith is a Jedi. I won't definitively say that they can't use abilities or powers from only one class. They can use the Force in whatever way they learn how. It's more fun that way. ~_^
Review By [DarthPayne] • Date [16 Jan 13] • Not Rated