Review of chapter "Did The Earth Move For You?" from Netchka
Review:
Cool story. Looking forward to reading more about Haldir and Dawns' adventures. Can't wait. :)
Comments from author:
Thank you - I really appreciate knowing that you are reading and enjoying it. The next chapter is taking shape nicely so I hope not to keep you waiting too long!
Review By [Netchka] • Date [12 Jun 13] • Rating [10 out of 10]
Review of chapter "Did The Earth Move For You?" from Luna
Review:
thanks for the update! im excited for them to meet namo :)
Also, I am super slow...after reading the other reviews I have no idea why the earth moved...the mountains moved? Is this a Valar thing? Eeek, I need coffee...
Comments from author:
It might take them a couple of chapters to get to meet Namo, yet.
As for what caused the earth to move - it may become clearer too, eventually!
Review of chapter "Did The Earth Move For You?" from Oxnate
Review:
I figured that was what it would be as soon as I read the title, but loved the double entendre.
Comments from author:
I said to Speaker-to-Customers that my first thought of a chapter title was that - and he said 'Go for it!', so just this once I took his advice - and did!
Review of chapter "The End of the Road" from SamuraiCatFan
Review:
Great story and series.
One might think that the Valar are using the requirement of the journey to Mandos as a test. After all, if she can get Haldir to actually adjust to life in Valinor, she will have shown that she has the ability to do the same for Spike (or at least get him adjusted to unlife in Valinor!) It is certainly going to be a different enviroment for Spike if he comes over, and the experience in dealing with Haldir will certainly help.
Sneaky Valar!
Comments from author:
Thank you. Oh yes - the Valar have definite reasons for Haldir being her companion on this trip!
Review By [SamuraiCatFan] • Date [17 May 13] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "The Road is Long..." from AndreaH
Review:
She's slowly winning over Haldir's grudging approval, isn't she? And perhaps snapping his head off and giving him information he hasn't been interested enough to find out for himself, or not listened to properly if he was told, will, eventually, make him snap himself out of his funk.
Go Tindómë go! Give him hell!
Great chapter :-)
Comments from author:
Thank you! It will doubtless do them both good to be thrown together. He is finding this new life to be not at all what he had expected - and it was really time that someone called him on a few misconceptions. And his younger sister-in-law is certainly a good person to do it....
But, then, I don't suppose his brothers actually did tell him how much they mourned him - it's probably not a topic easily discussed over a cup of tea!
Thank you! I wrote and rewrote this chapter, getting rid of unnecessary conversation early on - and then it was suddenly just the right place for this conversation instead.
Review of chapter "So Fair Thee Well, My Own True Love" from bookworm
Review:
I'm interested to see where this goes. I've enjoyed the whole series. Also, this has little to do with this story, but today I came across an encyclopedia-type blog entry on Rumil and Orophin, and I was curious to see whether their pictures look anything like your conception of the brothers. http://homeschoolblogger.com/walkinginmiddleearth/661441/ They seem to be from the movies, so I also wonder if they were actually meant to be these characters or if the blog authors just took screenshots of random elf-extras, but I expect you can't answer that. ;-)
Comments from author:
Thank you. It is always so nice to know that someone is enjoying the stories enough to take the time to let me know.
As for what the characters look like; as far as I can tell there were no original named parts in PJ's Fellowship of the Ring for Orophin and Rumil, but these two are recognised through much of fandom as being them, simply because of where they were standing, if you see what I mean!
I do have pictures in my own mind for them - I even have some saved. Perhaps I can put them onto here... I will try to add them to the time-line over the next couple of evenings. Because 'my' Orophin is not unlike the fandom one in that picture - but I think that that Rumil looks a bit too... um... rat-like? Not quite good-looking enough, anyway!
ETA - took a little longer than I meant to - but there are now pictures added to the time-line.
Review By [bookworm] • Date [10 Apr 13] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "So Fair Thee Well, My Own True Love" from Luna
Review:
Amazing! I love the map idea! Did you realize that, or read about it? Now, it all makes sense!
PS: Tolkien is a genius and I love him even more.
PSS: I love the idea of the Valar homes being 'pocket dimensions'.
PSSS: You are awesome and I really loved this update.
Comments from author:
I realized it all myself, when I was looking for maps. I thought 'that looks really familiar' and then it took me ages to find the map it reminded me of, if you see what I mean!
And I'm so glad that you like the idea of the pocket dimensions.