TtH • Reviews • The Guardian in Middle Earth: Part One

Review of chapter "Chapter One" from (Past Donor)

Review:

cool story

dont leave this ON HIATUS forever it be a shame its seems like the start to a really great epic

hope u pick it up again soon

Review By [ (Past Donor)

kaliGofD] • Date [16 Feb 08] • Rating [8 out of 10]

Review of chapter "Chapter One" from spk

Review:

I know that the summary says this story is on hiatus, but I sincerely hope you will pick it up soon. I LOVE Buffy/LotR crossovers, but most of them are abandoned. I really hope you will finish this because I'd love to see what you do with it, especially how the scythe will come into play. :)

Review By [spk] • Date [27 Jan 07] • Rating [7 out of 10]

Review of chapter "Chapter One" from Claddagh

Review:

I hope someday you come back to this. It really looks like it could be fun.

Review By [Claddagh] • Date [28 Dec 06] • Not Rated

Review of chapter "Chapter One" from UniilaDellaLuna

Review:

like keep it going

Review By [UniilaDellaLuna] • Date [4 Sep 06] • Rating [10 out of 10]

Review of chapter "Chapter One" from spk

Review:

Just re-reading what you have so far. I can't wait to read more. :)

Review By [spk] • Date [4 Aug 06] • Rating [6 out of 10]

Review of chapter "Prologue" from Iceflame

Review:

You've got a decent start here! You haven't disappeared, have you? Need my Buffy/LotR fix soon!

Comments from author:

Thanks so much. I haven't disappeared and I'm working on the next chapter of this. I'll be posting in the next week or so. Thanks for reviewing!

Review By [Iceflame] • Date [3 Aug 06] • Rating [10 out of 10]

Review of chapter "Chapter One" from willamthebloody

Review:

Loved the new chapter. To answer your question about adding book-verse elements, I think that would be a good idea. That way, you can bring in some really great characters like the twins and Glorfindel.

BTW, thanks for letting me know it won't be Buffy/Aragorn; either way, I still eagerly await the next chapter!

Review By [willamthebloody] • Date [21 Jul 06] • Rating [8 out of 10]

Review of chapter "Chapter One" from spk

Review:

Definitely loving it so far!!! :)

Comments from author:

Thanks so much for my review!

Review By [spk] • Date [2 Jul 06] • Rating [6 out of 10]

Review of chapter "Chapter One" from Cassie

Review:

have you posted this story on any other site cause I Have read both chapters before!

Comments from author:

Just at my site and my yahoo group.

Review By [Cassie] • Date [2 Jul 06] • Not Rated

Review of chapter "Chapter One" from danimc

Review:

Very cool. Only one problem, and that would be that you stopped when you did. So, as a remedy could you please update soon?

Comments from author:

LOL. Thanks for the very nice comment! I'm already working on chapter two and it should be out in the next week or so.

Review By [danimc] • Date [1 Jul 06] • Rating [9 out of 10]

Review of chapter "Chapter One" from CharmedSlayer

Review:

Very nice chapter, Though Im not sure whether I liked how you skipped ahead a year without giving us to much imformation about it. Perhaps you will do better in the next chapter. Good work though :)

Comments from author:

Thanks and no worries you will get flashbacks to what happened during that year throughout the story. Thanks for the review!

Review By [CharmedSlayer] • Date [1 Jul 06] • Rating [6 out of 10]

Review of chapter "Prologue" from fairieangel

Review:

I like your story so far! I especially loved the last line! Can't wait for more

Comments from author:

Thanks for the review!

Review By [fairieangel] • Date [15 Jun 06] • Rating [8 out of 10]

Review of chapter "Prologue" from CharmedSlayer

Review:

Im deffinately loving the way this story is heading.. I cannot wait to hear more
I do love how you used alot of Spike quotes.. I have to admit he is my favourite vamp of all time, HES THE BEST....anyway back to the story. It's excellently written and I do love the extreme detail that you put in and how you put everything into Buffy's point of view while sticking to the plot lines of the show. Please update soon its wicked

Comments from author:

Thanks for the review!

Review By [CharmedSlayer] • Date [2 Jun 06] • Rating [9 out of 10]

Review of chapter "Prologue" from willamthebloody

Review:

Great start! I hope you will continue with the story. I noticed that it's listed under the Buffy/Aragorn pairings. I absolutely love that pairing, but unfortunately, there are so few of them out there, (especially ones that are done well). So I hope you stick with that pairing.

Looking forward to reading more of this story!

Comments from author:

Ooops! This isn't a Buffy/Aragorn story. I'm sorry. I do have a Buffy/Aragorn in my 2 b written file, but this isn't one. Sorry...I'm gonna have to change that. Thanks for the heads up.

Review By [willamthebloody] • Date [22 Apr 06] • Rating [9 out of 10]

Review of chapter "Prologue" from musicgirl

Review:

Loved the Spike quote and W.W.S.D. Good stuff. Can't wait to see what happens...

Comments from author:

Hehe. I thought that was kinda funny. Thanks for the review!

Review By [musicgirl] • Date [11 Apr 06] • Rating [7 out of 10]