Large PrintHandheldAudioRating
Twisting The Hellmouth Crossing Over Awards - Results
Rules for Challenges


This has been stuck in my head for a while so I open it to all you lovely writers :)

Pairing: Buffy/Aragorn
any Rating
any Length


When Aragorn came of age not only was he told he was destined to be king but that his future Queen isn't from middle earth, & that he must find the Dagnir of his heart in another Dimension.

Aragorn is then sent to travel to the BTVS world to find the Dagnir meets Whistler & takes place of Angel in series except less cryptic & more action

story can be set in the LOTR with how Aragorn met Buf...
Lord of the Rings • (Past Donor)kaliGofD • Responses [0] • Date Added [17 Feb 08]
Xander is sent to Middle Earth about five years before the fellowship begin their journey. He stays there and eventually travels with them to destroy the ring.
Set after Buffy Season Three, but with no SuperXander.

It must have:
-Xander becoming a fighter
-Relationship can be slash
-GimliXander freindship, can be adopted as brother ect
-LegolasXander arguments, will get closer later on in the fic

It can't have
-Other buffy/angel characters, Xander has to be on his own
-Xander being picked on by other Scoobies
-To much on relationship/love. THIS...
Lord of the Rings • GoddessofSpring • Responses [0] • Date Added [10 Dec 07]
This is after The Gift, Buffy disappears in a portal and is reborn as Galadriel in Middle Earth.

Write a story about how she grows up and her marriage to Celeborn and her resurrection by Willow.
When Willow brings her back it can only be after Return of the King when they go to the Grey Havens.

You can also write more of Galadriel in the Lords of the Rings

Must have
Buffy/ Celeborn (of course)
She still got her powers in Middle Earth but also get the powers of Galadriel.

After her resurrection :
Buffy remembers her time in Middle Earth and ...
Lord of the Rings > Buffy-Centered > Pairing: Other LotR • Voldemort • Responses [1] • Date Added [28 Nov 07] • Date Updated [16 Jan 10]
What if when Buffy jumped through the portal (or any way you think of to cross to another verse) she ended up in her old home in Middle Earth. Done, right? Instead of having been an elf, what if she was the Daughter of Theoden King? Any pairings you want! Please!
Lord of the Rings • orlandosgurl • Responses [0] • Date Added [25 Sep 07]
Xander somehow ends up in the LOTR universe; preferably before the first book. Legolas finds him and they get off to a terrible start; violence ensures. Xander is captured and taken to the Elders. He is accepted by them and Legolas starts to fall for him.

Insert Xander into the LOTR storyline, feel free you can alter Canon to your hearts content.

In the end it should be Xander/Legolas, and I would like Xander to continuously rag Legolas about how they met. Extra points for the words "you shot me" showing up...
Lord of the Rings • KatHarris • Responses [0] • Date Added [17 Jul 07]
I've read a lot of stories where Buffy falls in love with Aragorn or Legolas. But what if she came to
ME years after the books/movies, and falls for Aragorn son?

timeline for Buffy:

- After season 7

Please let the hobbits make an appearance :)
Lord of the Rings • Angeluslover • Responses [0] • Date Added [16 Jun 07]
Someone falls through the Hellmouth and finds out that Hell is Middle-Earth, having lost the war against Sauron.

Did any of the LotR characters survive to create a rebellion? Can the Scoobies help them restore the throne of Men and neutralize the Hellmouth?
Lord of the Rings • RemingtonSmythe • Responses [1] • Date Added [31 May 07]
Familiar set-up, different fandom. One of the BtVS or AtS canon characters is transported to Middle Earth, but crossing dimensions causes a magical backlash, and as a result, they come out the other end of the portal as a child. From here, there are several options.

Option 1: Set the fic years before the Fellowship, when Aragorn is growing up among the elves as Estel, and make the BtVS end up among the elves as well, as a foster brother or sister to Aragorn and company. Alternatively, you could have him/her adopted by another major player (ie grow up as a sibling to Eowyn, or adopt...
Lord of the Rings • littleoldme • Responses [1] • Date Added [22 May 07]
I would love to see a story that starts in the first Age before the fall of Gondolin. I would like Buffy to be originally from Middle Earth or Valinor. She can originally be an Elf, Valar, or Maiar. I would like to see more than one elf interested in her but ultimately the pairing should be with Glorfindel.

To start out she is not the slayer, but she can have that fire that is purely Buffy. I would love to see you take your time for when she first falls in love with Glorfindel, but the pacing etc is your choice.

Glorfindel still dies defeating the Balrog in the fall ...
Lord of the Rings • (Past Donor)FireDragon • Responses [0] • Date Added [10 Apr 07] • Date Updated [12 Apr 07]
Set after Season Seven of Buffy:

Dawn accidentally opens a portal and she, Anya, Faith, and Andrew drop down on the Rangers of the North as they're going to meet up with Aragorn. Faith decides to help out with the battle and Dawn and the others go with her.

Pairings: Dawn/ Elrohir and Elladan
Faith/ Eomer
Anya/ Legolas
Andrew/ Eowyn

Must Have:
1. Faith ribbing Dawn on having to SO's.
2. Dawn being the Key makes her Immortal.
3. Andrew trying to explain Star Wars, Startrek, or D&D.
4. Anya ...
Lord of the Rings • Drix • Responses [0] • Date Added [29 Mar 07] • Date Updated [17 Jul 07]
While I'm a big Legomance fan, I have a real soft spot for the twins. As such, I'd love to see a Buffy/Elladan or Buffy/Elrohir 'ship especially as I haven’t seen one to date.

Typical Buffy falls into Earth here are some ideas for you to play with:

Rather than being found by Elrond, she instead captured by Sauron. Tortured for countless years (50+, no rape), he can not break her, and after failing to harness the true power of the Shadow's Child, for the entity that is the Slayer is eternal and a power greater than that of even the Necromancer himself, he makes her his i...
Lord of the Rings • Orcus • Responses [2] • Date Added [27 Mar 07]

Yes, that old chestnut where accidental use of the W word results in one of the Scoobies suddenly finding themselves in Middle Earth.

Then, one-by-one more Scoobies arrive as someone else accidentally uses the word, and so on.

Guidelines :
-- either Scoobies or ME dwellers can be the ones to use the forbidden word, but it should be a different person each time.
-- each time the use of the word is to be accidental ; once only the word can be used deliberately
-- Scoobies should arrive one at a time ; no more than 2 or more to be used twice, and...
Lord of the Rings > General > Theme: Fellowship • Nosi • Responses [0] • Date Added [15 Jan 07] • Date Updated [18 Jan 10]
I've seen plenty of Lord of the Rings flashbacks on this site, but I'd like to see one where the ageless substance of the Key is used in Sauron's Ring.

Now, it was created while Sauron had the loyalty of the elves (although he lost it during the forging). If the elves had allowed him access to a world-changing green energy they'd kept secret for millennia, he could have channeled its substance into the One Ring along with most of his power and his soul.

Crossover One:
When Buffy's sister dies, the Key energy is released. The Scoobies keep tabs on it, they're loyal ...
Lord of the Rings > Dawn-Centered • (Current Donor)Shieldage • Responses [0] • Date Added [3 Dec 06] • Date Updated [10 Jan 10]
I hereby challenge someone to write a LotR/BtVS crossover story in which the main character (BtVS) lands in middle earth (not original, I know). However this character is not allowed to first appear in good guy territory. For example, Buffy or willow or whoever could first appear in Mordor full of baddies, instead of the usual elvish realm. Gone are the usual elvish guides and even the Fellowship (at least in the beginning). You must also find a way for your BtVS character to become important to the survival of middle earth.

After these conditions, the storyline is fair game. The ...
Lord of the Rings • linny • Responses [0] • Date Added [29 Nov 06] • Date Updated [4 Apr 07]
Perhaps this has been done before (if so, please forgive the overlap), but I haven't seen it so I'm posting the challenge here.

It was said that the line of Lúthien would never fail. What if all of the Slayers are of her line? Now, suppose one of the Maiar who served Morgoth and repented after the War of Wrath decides after all these millennia that he or she wants to return to Middle Earth, enslave the Second Born, and rule as a God? Perhaps he or she persuades a few fellow Maiar to come along as well?

For purposes of this challenge, pretend Tolkien never wrote his storie...
Lord of the Rings • (Current Donor)Sulien • Responses [0] • Date Added [20 Jul 06] • Date Updated [15 Jul 08]
start back Page: 3 of 4 next end