Large PrintHandheldAudioRating
Twisting The Hellmouth Crossing Over Awards - Results
Rules for Challenges

No One Mourns the Wicked

StoryReviewsStatisticsRelated StoriesTracking
Review of chapter "No One Mourns the Wicked" from Gideon
This Maggie Walsh is no longer an evil caricature, she is evil with a reason, which can be much more dangerous. And worse yet, she has a real incentive to do her work *badly* I think she would make a good Goauld ;)
Comments from author:
Technically, she's human. With a reason to hate the NID and very few moral qualms. THAT makes her dangerous.
Review By [Gideon] • Date [8 Oct 11] • Rating [8 out of 10]
Review of chapter "No One Mourns the Wicked" from tenchifew
Nice take on Maggie Walsh. It is very rare that a human being is competely "evil" or "good". Usually there are a plethora of shades of grey and even the "evil ones" did not usually started out fully corrupted. It is good to see a take on a more human Maggie.
Thank you for writing.
Comments from author:
"There are precious few at ease, with moral ambiguities. So we pretend they don't exist." - The wizard

Thank you for liking it. And for recommending. I really wasn't expecting that.
Review By [tenchifew] • Date [8 Oct 11] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "No One Mourns the Wicked" from Genuka
Well, that certainly shifted my world view on Walsh drastically. You truly are evil. You do realize that playing with your readers minds is dangerously close to the convention of forbidden mental arts set down in 1863 right? *smirk*

Should you(or anyone else) choose to use that totally fictional convention/treaty feel free. I only ask that I be cited. *evil grin of doom providing plot bunnies!!!!!!!*

I'm glad I could make you happy; and I totally understand about the "yeah, she's evil... I wonder why?" Happens to me all the time and drives my family nuts because I windup deconstructing the personality/character and putting it back together without the twisting/corrupting influence and see how it was originally meant to be seen and they just don't get it. Much less how I can see that one out of the originally presented one.
Comments from author:
If I opened one person's mind, then I'm happy. I remember watching the series the first time and going, "Yeah, she's evil", but I watched it again to start writing fics and I just couldn't see it any more.
Review By [Genuka] • Date [7 Oct 11] • Rating [10 out of 10]
Review of chapter "No One Mourns the Wicked" from esketerra
Vaccines prevent viruses, not genetic disorders - Down Syndrome is Trisomy 21 aka 3 copies of the 21st chromosome. So it's a genetic disorder, and it's generally a new mutation, not inherited from a parent who also had T21. It's not a disease and a vaccine of any type would be useless even a magical pretend vaccine - there is nothing to vaccinate against. Complications like heart defects and early onset dementia need to be treated & a cure for those would be great but the idea T21 itself needs to be cured is very offensive. Then again, Maggie is kind of an evil character so if that's the goal, go for it. If you're trying to make her sympathetic, I'd make her try to cure her sister's fatal illness or something, not a developmental disability. I am interested to see more about Maggie since she's hardly ever even mentioned in fic. (I came to this fic by way of the previous one in the series & am enjoying that one a lot - just didn't have anything else to add over there that other people hadn't covered yet in reviews.)
Comments from author:
No, that wasn't the goal. I just don't really understand Down Syndrome other than it was genetic.

I had a lot more planned for Maggie at one time. But test reads showed me that she's REALLY hated by some people. We'll see how people respond to this and the blurb in the other story. Most future action will probably take place there.

Thank you for your review. I apologize for my ignorance.
Review By [esketerra] • Date [7 Oct 11] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "No One Mourns the Wicked" from CageFire
Well that's not as bad as I thought, just some background.
Comments from author:
Thank you. Out of curiosity, how bad did you think it would be?
Review By [CageFire] • Date [7 Oct 11] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "No One Mourns the Wicked" from CaffeineAddict
It's different, and I kind of like it, one minor nitpick however is the fact that Down Syndrome can't be "caught", it's a syndrome which stems from an extra chromosome and thus a vaccine would be impossible unless given to the potential parents, and that's less a vaccine and more gene therapy as it's a recessive trait (from what little I remember from high school science classes).
Comments from author:
I realized that it can't be caught. Not really sure what caused it. Whatever it was Maggie was sure she was going to "cure" it.

Edit: I seem to have lost your recommendation. Since you're one of my earliest reviews, I was wondering if there was anything I did? Or can do?
Review By [CaffeineAddict] • Date [7 Oct 11] • Not Rated
start back Page: 2 of 2
StoryReviewsStatisticsRelated StoriesTracking