Review of chapter "What Makes The Men We Are" from
wonderbeeReview:
Found myself nodding along with Kirk there, and quite agree, the way the crew basically got shoved into the command of the Enterprise from the last movie made me wonder what exactly Starfleet was thinking, and SFDebris Ina review said it best, Alt Kirk is not forged by all the difficulties canon Kirk had, and that makes him lacking IMO.
Review By [
wonderbee] • Date [24 Oct 12] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "What Makes The Men We Are" from
RevDorothyLReview:
Really thought-provoking! Who better than Jim Kirk to discern the possible down-side to a younger, more free-wheeling and emotionally damaged Jim Kirk with a younger, more aggressive and equally supportive Bones and Spock to back him up, in charge of a kick-ass ship and a forged-in-hell crew?
Review By [
RevDorothyL] • Date [24 Oct 12] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "What Makes The Men We Are" from
PhilisterReview:
This story closely mirrors my own thinking about the 2009 Trek movie. Giving a not-even-graduated-yet cadette permanent command of a starship? And not even an experienced crew of officers to back him up? It boggles the mind. And I can easily imagine young Shatner giving the other Kirk suspicious glances. Very nicely written.
Review By [
Philister] • Date [24 Oct 12] • Not Rated
