Review of chapter "Chapter 7" from iceyflame
This is really good so far. I am sick and tired of all the Legolas/Buffy pairings, this is a nice change. I can't wait till you bring Haldir in, thats going to be awesome. I have been looking for a Buffy/Haldir or Buffy/Faramir for ages now. That would be an interesting pair. I am enjoying it so far, I can't wait till you update. Thanks!
Review By [iceyflame
] • Date [24 Mar 05] • Not Rated
Review of chapter "Chapter 7" from jammiesMM
Cool update. I think it is cool that you had Dawn learn to use a bow and sword. I always thought Buffy should have let Dawn at least learn to defend herself better. Because if you think about it Dawn herself is the "final protector" of the 'key'. And I know Dawn is not a slayer but she was made from Buffy who was the slayer so I believe 'part' of the slayer is in Dawn after all the elven part was. So her learning so well/quickly is cool. It was funny how they both decided to wear the different clothes but were exactly alike. LOL I am glad their brothers accepted Dawn as well. It must be something about the power of the 'key' as to why the ring doesn't effect Dawn maybe because the power of the key can destroy the whole universe which could actually make if more powerful then the ring? Keep writing this is good. One thing though for some reason 'chapter 1' is out of order and it at like chapter 5. Update soon
Review By [jammiesMM
] • Date [19 Mar 05] • Rating [9 out of 10]
Review of chapter "Chapter 5" from acs
I'm enjoying this very much. Some interesting ideas.
But... you might want to check your chapter titles and the order of chapter's 4 thru 6. I believe one of them is out of order (Or maybe it's just me). You also might want to try using TtH's wonderful review reply feature :-).
Review By [acs
] • Date [5 Mar 05] • Rating [9 out of 10]
Review of chapter "Chapter 3" from Naurolim
Well I am thoroughly enjoying this fic so far and can't wait to read more.
I am glad that this is going to be Buffy/Haldir as you don't get many of those fics and Dawn/Legolas should be interesting.
I am ejoying the character interaction so far and would love to see the twins reaction to Buffy's return and to having another sister.
Looking forward to the Council meeting.
To get a 10 you gotta finish :)
Review By [Naurolim
] • Date [18 Feb 05] • Rating [9 out of 10]
Review of chapter "Chapter 3" from jammiesMM
This is cool. I like how you have that both of them fell/jumped into the portal. Most of the time it is just Buffy. I was not a big fan of Dawn but I like her so far. I like it that their father accepted her so well Dawn really needed that because her earth father was never there so her having a father now is cool. So since she is only 4monthes old (technically) how old is she in Middle Earth? LOL She was supposed to be what 3-4yrs younger then Buffy so I wonder how much younger she is here. Anyway keep writing this is very interesting.
Review By [jammiesMM
] • Date [17 Feb 05] • Rating [9 out of 10]
Review of chapter "Chapter 2" from Goddessa
This sounds cool and I hope you continue. Do you think you could bring Angel and maybe even Spike over, and make it BA and possible DS? Pleeeeeeeeeease.... that would be so cool. :)
Review By [Goddessa
] • Date [13 Feb 05] • Rating [9 out of 10]
Review of chapter "Chapter 2" from immortalwizardelffan
I like this fic, I like it a lot. kinda different form all of the otehr Buffy is Elrond's daughter LOTR/Buffy crossovers. And also the fact that both of them jumped makes it different as well. Usually it's either Dawn or Buffy who jumps not both. I like the way that you have Arwen, Buffy and Dawn interacting as frinds and sisters.
I just can't wait to read the reaction of Elrond, Gandalf, Aragorn, Legolas, Gimli, the Hobbits, and Boromir when they find out that Buffy can kick ass easily. And if you're going to have Legolas and Dawn & Haldir and Buffy be the couples does that mean Buffy and Dawn are going with the fellowship? And if so, does that mean Sauron and Saruman know that Dawn is 'the Key' of Dimensions and the girls have to go in order to keep Dawn safe?
Review By [immortalwizardelffan
] • Date [12 Feb 05] • Rating [9 out of 10]
Review of chapter "Chapter 2" from NoLifeKing
I like it, much!!! Nice new idea to make them both eldar and daughters of Elrond.
Does Buffy still have her slayer powers? Without them I don't see a reason for her to accompanying the fellowship. :-/
I look forward how that will be develop. And I hope for the next chapter(s) soon! ;-)
Review By [NoLifeKing
] • Date [9 Feb 05] • Rating [9 out of 10]
Review of chapter "Chapter 2" from zephyrRS
Interesting tale thus far. I enjoy the idea of Buffy and Dawn getting a real chance to be sisters together in a different world. I look forward to seeing this story grow.
Review By [zephyrRS
] • Date [9 Feb 05] • Rating [8 out of 10]
Review of chapter "New Journeys" from Ashes
Elenwë? Turgon's wife? That's different. In a good way I mean. I don't know about you but seriously geeting tired of all those Buffy-drops-in-on-the-cousel-and-legolas-waits-with-her-till-she-wakes-up-joins-the-fellowship fics. I needed something different badly. Please continue. This fic looks really promising.
Review By [Ashes
] • Date [7 Feb 05] • Rating [8 out of 10]